> It seems that they have a device ( modem ) that has to be used to give
> IP address by "dhcp" to all systems.

Most of the UK's ADSL network is PPPoA rather than the more common PPPoE you 
might see elsewhere in the world. You generally need an ADSL modem to present 
an Ethernet connection to your preferred firewall/router (pfSense one assumes 
:-) )

> And even if you want to give Static IPs ( routable on the Internet )
> assigned to you by BT on any of your servers you should first assign
> the server an IP in the local range through dhcp and then get into the
> BT device's web interface and assign the Static IP through that
> interface to the appropriate server.

The device provided by BT is usually a re-badged Thomson Speedtouch in one of 
its many guises. Essentially it's a router with an inbuilt ADSL modem and a 
cut-down web interface. The "assign an IP in the local range and assign the 
Static IP through that" is essentially the same as pfSense's 1:1 NAT capability 
by another name.

> How do the British people use pfSense as the firewall while using BT
> as their ISP?

Simply use a PPPoA ADSL modem/router with NAT disabled. From your static IP 
range, give the modem one, pfSense another, and what you have left you can use 
on the servers. The phone line (RJ11) goes into the ADSL modem, the modem 
(RJ45) goes into your pfSense box.

Personally, my inclination would be to not use BT as my ISP, but that's purely 
a personal opinion. Unfortunately over the last year or two the UK has seen a 
few large ISPs offering stupidly low prices without sufficient network 
investment to cover the bandwidth requirements. Generally, this means that 
around 4pm when the kids come home from school, speeds drop off and latency 
skyrockets.

Most ADSL providers in the UK use the BT network to deliver the ADSL to the end 
user, but have much more control over things like traffic routing, IPs, etc. 
once it leaves the BT network and ATM layer, so you can safely use an ISP apart 
from BT without the end user having to use different equipment or get different 
lines put in.

> I asked the sysadmin there and he said they just use the firewall on
> the BT device (modem) and that the device cannot be done away with or
> configured to allow us to define static IPs on the interface of our
> Servers using the config files on the servers Operating System.
> Is this true?

No, absolutely not. You can use any PPPoA capable ADSL modem/router. If your 
ISP has assigned you a range of static IPs (e.g. a /29) I tend to put the ADSL 
modem on one of them, pfSense on another, leaving 4 IPs for distribution 
between servers as required. The ADSL modem/router doesn't need to be anything 
fancy - you aren't going to be using its firewall - it exists purely to convert 
to an Ethernet presentation. I use cheap £20 Dynamode R-ADSL-C04 units. They're 
Conexant-based, reliable, easy to configure and low-cost.

> And what are the other ISPs other than BT in U.K especially in the Bolton 
> Area?

(shameless plug)
We are an ADSL provider to the whole of the UK through BT's wholesale network 
and can provide blocks of static IPs as required. I don't want to go into 
commercial stuff on this list, so please contact me off-list if you want to 
pursue this.
(/shameless plug)

Regards,

Chris
-- 
C.M. Bagnall, Director, Minotaur I.T. Limited
For full contact details visit http://www.minotaur.it
This email is made from 100% recycled electrons



---------------------------------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
For additional commands, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]

Reply via email to