Hello,

Short Problem Description: Starting the Backup Server results in 50% (or more) 
packet loss on the WAN facing Interfaces. I saw in the states table that it 
seems that the Backup server is sending packets to over the Master Server, or 
so it seems. Maybe I have a basic issue in my setup, though I am not a network 
newbie, I am not a GURU either. 

Background: 
I am currently setting up what will be our new Firewall and Gateway system. In 
the end we will have a Multi WAN Setup with 5 or 6 WAN Interfaces, some 
loadbalanced for internet access, some for dedicated Services.

I have two Servers, fw-01 (PFSense Master) and fw-02 (PFSense Backup).

Currently I have 2 WAN Interfaces connected (at OPT1 and OPT2, I do not use the 
WAN Interface as I did not setup VLANS before assigning the interfaces, and I 
need VLAN's for all my WAN connections, could this be a problem or does it not 
matter?)

All WAN Interfaces have a /28 network with .14 set as the gateway IP for this 
network. The Internet Routers have mostly static public IP's, but I do not have 
the luxury of having more than one Public IP, so the router do NAT for the 
internal interfaces.

I hope someone can point me at where the problem seems to be, if you need any 
more information I am happy to provide it!

best regards
Ray

Ascii Art of my Setup:

    PUBLIC   1.1.1.1           2.2.2.2
             Router A          Router B         WLAN Router 1-6
             10.100.101.14     10.100.102.14    10.100.202.240-246
                   |                 |                |
                   |                 |                |
                   |                 |                |
    VLAN          101               102              202
    IF       10.100.101.2      10.100.102.2     10.100.202.253
    CARP     10.100.101.1      10.100.102.1     10.100.202.254
             OPT1 (/28)        OPT2 (/28)       OPT3 (/24)
                  |                |                |
                  |                |                |
  Unused     ,''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''|
  WAN        |                  PFSense  MASTER               |
             `................................................|
                    |               |
    CARP     192.168.3.254
    IF       192.168.3.253      10.100.200.2
             LAN (/22)          OPT4 (PFSync)







   PUBLIC   1.1.1.1           2.2.2.2
            Router A          Router B         WLAN Router 1-6
            10.100.101.14     10.100.102.14    10.100.202.240-246
                  |                 |                |
                  |                 |                |
                  |                 |                |
   VLAN          101               102              202
   IF       10.100.101.3      10.100.102.3     10.100.202.252
   CARP     10.100.101.1      10.100.102.1     10.100.202.254
            OPT1 (/28)        OPT2 (/28)       OPT3 (/24)
                 |                |                |
                 |                |                |
 Unused     ,''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''|
 WAN        |                  PFSense  BACKUP               |
            `................................................|
                   |               |
   CARP     192.168.3.254
   IF       192.168.3.252      10.100.200.3
            LAN (/22)          OPT4 (PFSync)


                


---------------------------------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe, e-mail: [email protected]
For additional commands, e-mail: [email protected]

Commercial support available - https://portal.pfsense.org

Reply via email to