>> Would you then recommend removing trailing comma support for collections on 
>> the same principle?
me too — so, for the review-part: -0.5, no trailing commas (it's not a full -1 
as long as I'm not forced to add those trailing commas)
I don't think they are convenient, and even if that is wrong: The 
convenience-argument could be used to cripple the language (skipping closing 
parens could be convenient, using "l" and "v" instead of "let" & "var" could be 
convenient, inferring the return-type of methods could be convenient... and 
possibly hundreds of small changes in the syntax as well).
The idea of using newlines as separators (making "," obsolete, like ";" in 
other situations) imho is much nicer and would address the same issues that 
this proposal tries to improve.
_______________________________________________
swift-evolution mailing list
[email protected]
https://lists.swift.org/mailman/listinfo/swift-evolution

Reply via email to