> On Oct 25, 2016, at 10:38 AM, Jay Abbott via swift-evolution
> <[email protected]> wrote:
>
> I mentioned this in passing on a different thread
> <https://lists.swift.org/pipermail/swift-evolution/Week-of-Mon-20161024/028371.html>.
> Although it caused some slight confusion when I first learned the 'guard'
> keyword, it was easy to overcome and I didn't think the issue was strong
> enough to warrant a change. However, after reading the other discussion on
> that thread (around the possibility of a 'matches' keyword and how code is
> "read out" or "internally verbalised"), and seeing how passionate everyone
> here is about Swift, I'm thinking that maybe it should be changed.
>
> The issue is that in English, 'guard' has an inverted logical connotation to
> how it is used in Swift. For example, take this sentence:
>
> "In some functions it's a good idea is to put some checks in place, in order
> to guard against invalid input values."
>
> Swift's 'guard' keyword is to guard against invalid values.
> Or to put it another way, to ensure that we have valid values.
>
> However, the way it reads in Swift, we guard that we have valid values.
>
> I fully understand and agree that it's better to state the true condition for
> valid values here, using else to perform a contingency. And I understand why
> the word 'guard' was picked (given the above example sentence). I just think
> that 'ensure' would be better.
>
> ensure x > 0 else {
> return
> }
>
> ensure camp.isSafe else {
> runForTheHills()
> }
>
> ensure let thingy = object as? Thingy else {
> return ExamineThingyResult.NotAThingy
> }
>
> As I said, I thought it was too small a niggle to worry about, but seeing how
> people on here care so much about making Swift better, and the willingness to
> change things, I thought I'd suggest it. Although it would be a breaking
> change, the code changes are easy.
>
> So what do people think? In particular it would be interesting to hear from
> non-native English speakers on this, did 'guard' confuse you or did 'guard'
> cause your understanding of the English word to be confused?
“Guard” is a computer science term for a test that must pass for execution to
continue. Given that, I don’t think changing the keyword is warranted.
Preston
_______________________________________________
swift-evolution mailing list
[email protected]
https://lists.swift.org/mailman/listinfo/swift-evolution
