Here is an unusual situation seen from our network (AS 8237).

Our direct SwissIX peering with Genotec has been down for a few weeks now
(can someone from Genotec contact me about this). Since then we have noticed
the following effect:


If our traffic to Genotec is routed via AS 6775, then we are unable to
establish an FTP connection to Genotec, although WWW works as usual.


# traceroute to gic-web-bsd-016.genotec.ch (82.195.224.116): 1-30 hops, 38 byte 
packets
 1  ZHS08 (195.216.80.8)  0.268 ms  0.146 ms  0.115 ms
 2  as6775.swissix.ch (194.242.34.40)  2.41 ms  1.57 ms  2.62 ms
 3  ge0.2.border-01.iwb.ipv4.as16215.net (194.242.34.16)  2.95 ms (ttl=252!)  
3.17 ms (ttl=252!)  2.48 ms (ttl=252!)
 4  *  *  *
 5  *  *  *
 6
(interrupt)


# telnet 82.195.224.116 21
Trying 82.195.224.116...
(Timeout)


# telnet 82.195.224.116 80
Trying 82.195.224.116...
Connected to 82.195.224.116.
Escape character is '^]'.




However if the traffic goes through another AS (e.g. AS 13030), then everything
is fine.


# traceroute 82.195.224.116
traceroute to gic-web-bsd-016.genotec.ch (82.195.224.116): 1-30 hops, 38 byte 
packets
 1  ZHS08 (195.216.80.8)  0.247 ms  0.128 ms  0.175 ms
 2  swissix-zh.init7.net (194.242.34.7)  0.677 ms (ttl=62!)  4.0 ms (ttl=62!)  
0.659 ms (ttl=62!)
 3  r1bas.ce.init7.net (213.144.128.57)  1.43 ms  3.86 ms  1.41 ms
 4  gw-genotec.init7.net (77.109.134.170)  2.17 ms  2.15 ms  2.47 ms
 5  *  *  *
 6  *  *  *
 7  *  *  *
 8
(interrupt)


# telnet 82.195.224.116 21
Trying 82.195.224.116...
Connected to 82.195.224.116.
Escape character is '^]'.
220-
220-                                                         .y/
220-  ::::::. ::::::.    -oso+s/  `+ooo/`  os+oso.  `/oso+` `sMd+` `/ooo/`  
`/oso+`
220- `o-```/:`o.```/:   `mm-.+My `dm/:+Ny  mN:.:Nd` yN:.-md` /My.  dm/:/Nh  
dm:.-:`
220- `/::::/- /::::/-   .Nh  .My .Nd+++o+` mm   dm` dm   hN. -Ms  `Md+++oo `Nh
220- `/::::/- /::::/-    odysyMy  odyosy-  dm   dm` /dhsyd+  `ddo` +dyosy:  
+dysys`
220- `o.   /:`o.   /:    `:--+Mo   `...`   ..   ..   `...`    `..   `...`    
`...`
220- `::::::. ::::::.    -osss:
220-
220-                              Genotec Internet Consulting AG
220-                              Hegenheimermattweg 119a, CH-4104 Allschwil BL
220-                              email: [EMAIL PROTECTED] --- http: 
www.genotec.ch
220-
220-
220 FTP server ready



Is AS 6775 really filtering port 21 at the backbone level? That would clearly 
be quite unusual.

Can anyone else see this effect?

For the time being, I am disabling our peering to AS 6775, but it would be nice 
for whoever
it concerns to look into this.


Kind regards
Anthony


-- 
|  Anthony Uk            |  dataway GmbH     |  Tel. +41 44 299 9988   | 
|  [EMAIL PROTECTED]         |  Hohlstrasse 216  |  Fax  +41 44 299 9989   | 
|  PGP key ID 10DE1D2C   |  CH-8021 Zuerich  |  http://www.dataway.ch  | 
_______________________________________________
swinog mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.swinog.ch/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/swinog

Antwort per Email an