On Wed, 29 Jan 2003 15:15:40 +0000, Daniel Lorch <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> said:
> Ok, I admit -- I'm annoying. In a nutshell: It's worse now; problem not
> solved.

Maybe we should ask ourselves what problem we want to solve.

The former situation was that there were two name servers for
swinog.ch sharing infrastructure (even if they had redundant
upstreams, there were actual failures of the underlying fiber network
that took both out at the same time).

So people couldn't resolve swinog.ch names, although some of the
things under swinog.ch were functioning perfectly.

That problem will have been solved now (at soon as the swinog.ch
delegation has been changed).

> Solution: Increase TTL, remove unnecessary secondary DNSes.

Increasing the TTLs is a fine idea, but there will always be
situations when a cached record has eventually timed out, and if you
cannot reach any authoritative name server, you'll be hosed.

You will agree that we shouldn't make TTLs *infinitely* large, because
we still want the possibility of changing addresses in finite time for
some reasons (think of emergency situations).
-- 
Simon.
----------------------------------------------
[EMAIL PROTECTED] Maillist-Archive:
http://www.mail-archive.com/swinog%40swinog.ch/

Reply via email to