Let me make this clear upfront: all of my posts on GitHub, including this one, rely on translation by an LLM.
I believe it would be reasonable to explicitly state in the policy that spam-like PRs and PRs relying heavily on LLMs are prohibited. Along with that, the policy should also clarify that such PRs may be proactively closed without prior notice, and that there should be a clear process for appealing an incorrect closure. To reduce the review burden, one possible approach would be to require all PRs to undergo an initial review by Copilot before human review. However, I am not sure how capable Copilot actually is. 2025年11月12日水曜日 23:01:46 UTC+9 Oscar: > On Wed, 5 Nov 2025 at 22:50, Francesco Bonazzi <[email protected]> > wrote: > > > > Maybe it should be made mandatory to disclose any usage of LLM when > opening PRs. > > There needs to be at the very least a policy that bans using LLMs > without saying that they were used. There should be checkboxes when > opening a PR: > > [x] I have or have not used an LLM > [x] I have checked the code from the LLM > [x] I have tested the code myself > [x] I do/don't understand all of the code that was generated by the LLM. > > > Banning usage of LLM completely is a bit extreme, but it may be > necessary if vibe spammers keep flooding github with useless PRs. > > Using LLMs to generate comments and PR descriptions should just be > banned outright with an exception for google translate type use only. > Obviously this cannot be enforced but the messaging needs to be clear: > don't dump LLM output as if it is a comment from yourself. > > As for use of LLMs for writing code I don't necessarily object to > simple autocomplete type LLMs for convenience but I think if you look > at typical PRs and contributors right now they really should not be > using LLMs at all. The LLMs only seem to help people to make > time-wasting vibe-code PRs where the "author" has no understanding of > the code they are submitting and has not even done basic testing. > > -- > Oscar > -- You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups "sympy" group. To unsubscribe from this group and stop receiving emails from it, send an email to [email protected]. To view this discussion visit https://groups.google.com/d/msgid/sympy/3701d3d3-3e8d-4607-b900-f0bac93b9fe7n%40googlegroups.com.
