On Viernes 22 Octubre 2010 18:29:58 M∡rtin Koppenhoefer escribió: > 2010/10/22 Noel David Torres Taño <env...@rolamasao.org>: > > On Viernes 22 Octubre 2010 17:58:04 Peter Budny escribió: > >> > What is wrong with the operator=* or brand=* tags? > >> > >> +1 to both > >> > >> name=* to me would equate to the name that appears on my bank statement, > >> like "Student Center Post Office ATM" or "Lenox Square Mall ATM". It > >> sounds like what you're describing fits in operator=* or brand=*. > >> > >> I don't know about network=*... even though they're called "networks", > >> that seems like a different meaning from the existing uses of network=* > >> in OSM. > > > > I've asked about this too. I can understand that name=* refers to a > > specific name of the particular ATM, like "Lenox Square Mall ATM" as you > > said. But where to write "Banca March" (bank) and where to write > > "Servired" (network)? Which one is operator=* and which one is brand=* ? > > operator is Banca March (the bank that set up the atm and puts money > in when it's empty), the network is "Servired" and this could also be > expressed as brand. > > This might be OK for most cases. I can imagine cases where it creates > problems, because network could be more then one, brand could then > refer to the brand of the bank that set up the atm and operator would > be the bank that operates it. Brand and operator are not the same in > all cases. Using brand with multiple values feeld incorrect to me, > because it is not the brands of the atm but it is networks where it is > affiliated with. > > cheers, > Martin
It is not the same which network an ATM is in (it is only one) and which cards it can work with (this can be multiple). For example, the ATM I have just in from of my flat is operated by CajaCanarias (a "caja" is bank-like organisation typical of Spain), it belongs to the Red 6000 network like all CajaCanarias' ATMs and all ATMs from other cajas, and it accepts Visa, MasterCard, Cirrus, American Express and other cards. Cards emitted by CajaCanarias can be Maestro, MasterCard or Visa but they always carry the Red 6000 logo, and I can use them without fees in all ATMs from CajaGalicia, CAM, CajaCM and others, but I can not use it freely on Servired ATMs like Banca March, CajaMadrid, BBVA or Banco Santander: it will work, but I will pay fees. So, operator=CajaCanarias brand=Red 6000 ? Thanks Noel er Envite _______________________________________________ Tagging mailing list Tagging@openstreetmap.org http://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/tagging
