Of course the person doing this merge should exercise due diligence.
If their records show a store is closed, but OSM shows it as open, the
person should call the store or somehow verify the information is
correct and up to date.

Based on this I'll added to the "diff" seen by the mapper.
I can show the comments tag in the summary.  So the merge run might produce:

Source key 5: name="Big Chain"
Osm    key 5: name="Big Chain (CLOSED)"
Osm key 5: comment="This store was burned to the ground by anti-Canadian mobs"
Osm    key 5: userid=goodMapper

Source key 6: name="Big Chain"
Osm    key 6: name="Big Chain HIRES ILLEGAL CANADIAN WORKERS"
Osm    key 6: userid=vanalHaxxer

Source key 7: name="Big Chain"
Osm    key 7: name="Big Chain HIRES ILLEGAL CANADIANWORKERS"
Osm    key 7: userid=vanalHaxxer

Source key 8: name="Big Chain"
Osm    key 8: name="Big Chain HIRES ILLEGAL CANADIAN WORKERS"
Osm    key 8: userid=vanalHaxxer

Add key 1: name="Big Chain" (the tool won't discover that vanalHaxxer deleted store #1) Add key 2: name="Big Chain" (the tool won't discover that vanalHaxxer deleted store #2) Add key 3: name="Big Chain" (the tool won't discover that vanalHaxxer deleted store #3) Add key 4: name="Big Chain" (the tool won't discover that vanalHaxxer deleted store #4)



So in the end is the tool considered harmful?

_______________________________________________
Tagging mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/tagging

Reply via email to