Hi! 2013/1/15 Ronnie Soak <[email protected]>: > Best solution I could come up with: tag the whole thing as > leisure=water_park [1] (even if it is not that fancy as in the wiki > definition), tag the water features as leisure=swimming_pool[2](even if you > can't swim in some) and sport=swimming for those you actually can (e.g. not > for the childrens basin).
I agree with you there. > (I may also add landuse=basin, but this may be overkill.) I don't think it's overkill I think it's wrong. Although a swimming pool is "An area of land artificially graded to hold water." it doesn't feel right. Have a look at the subkey "basin" and its values. > Tag the playing fields as e.g. leisure=pitch, sport=volleyball, > surface=sand, > further features as amenity = playground, amenity=showers, amenity=toilets, > amenity=fast_food etc, mostly attached to a building=yes if appropriate. > The green around would be a leisure=park, landcover=grass. Hm... is leisure=park really useful/correct here. You already tagged the whole area with leisure=water_park and in my understanding this means that everything that's not tagged as a specific feature or building is green. > Now the question is where to put the name, opening_hours etc. I did put it > on the leisure=water_park border, because it is the overall thing. I briefly > toyed with the idea to create a site relation with all those things inside > and place it there, but then I realized that in a spatial database, there is > no need to artifically group things based on their position inside a > boundary. You can do a 'is in?' query to such a database. Fully agree. Especially about the site-relation - we don't need that here. > So, can we discuss if this is a good approach or what can be made better and > then document that in the wiki? At the moment, there are various examples on > how to tag single-building swimming pools but bigger places are not > mentioned. I think the best place for some additional documentation would be the article about leisure=water_park. We should add there a list of related features with examples and links to the keys. > Worst I've seen in the wild was a leisure=swimming_pool on a multipolygon > cutting out the actual water areas. wtf? Call it creativity ;-) regards, Martin _______________________________________________ Tagging mailing list [email protected] http://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/tagging
