> +1, also if they don't have something more in common I'd go this way.
They have in common that you can put books into both. > The > other place you wrote about of that allows to bring and pick-up different > stuff could maybe also be a kind of shop? No. Its just the same without the limitation to books. > if there was a tradeoff for bicycles they would not have a lot in > common with the book ones. The idea of sharing: To be able to leave something and to pick something. > In the university, there I've studied there was a place, there you could > leave smaller things, which everyone could pick off for free. This could be a > t-shirt or mp3-player or a pc-game or whatever... This is similar to a shelf I know from a pub. There you can put everything you like which fits into it. > So I think it would be better to have a general tag for such a place (leave > something, which you don't need any more and someone else can pick off this). > If there is a limitation (eg. only books) this could be tagged additionally. +1 > This is quite close to the question, how to tag collection bins for charity > shops: > http://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Talk:Tag:shop%3Dcharity The difference is the size. The public bookcase are just a shelf and you do not get in contact with money. May be the "trade" at tradeoff is misleading. So we probably need another word. > For places to get things for free, one could maybe use shop=* and then some > other tag to show it is for free. Maybe payment=free. One problem might be the specification. Since its only for books you could use shop=books (which would be misleading - just an example). But for no specific stuff I do not know at value. > amenity=reuse > reuse:books=yes This could be a better alternative for tradeoff. I did not find a wiki-article. Is there one? _______________________________________________ Tagging mailing list [email protected] http://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/tagging
