On 24/06/2015 5:54 PM, Kotya Karapetyan wrote:
Hi,
I wonder: Could we try to slightly change the proposal/RFC process to
make the community develop the good solution?
It is obvious that only a small amount of people voted against the
proposal as such, thinking it's not useful.
The majority complained about the specific wording.
There were a significant number against 'desk' (4 voice concerns over
'desk').
One is still against 'amenity'.
Difficult to make out what some concerns are about or to make out a
change that would be suitable.
The wording of the wiki changes over time as wiki edits take placed.
Most of this activity is 'polishing' - small changes to improve the
meaning and/or comprehension. I'm not too worried about this, as long as
the basic intention remains.
We could put several voting sections in one wiki-page, something like
this:
Reception point/desk/facility proposal
Reception provides a place where people arrive to be greeted...
Proposed tagging:
amenity = reception_point
yes
yes
no
no
...
amenity = reception_desk
yes
no
yes
no
...
People would be able to add their own versions, and vote. The winning
suggestion becomes the final wording.
It would also have the advantage of keeping comments next to the votes
rather than in this mailing list. The mailing list is clearly good for
discussion, but not so much for the final stage, when the proposer
needs the community feedback. At that moment suddenly those who
haven't heard arguments are asked for their opinion.
Nice idea ... but I have started down this path so will continue. It
would have been usefull for blood donations too. And temperature would
certainly benefit for such a change.
_______________________________________________
Tagging mailing list
[email protected]
https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/tagging
