W dniu 21.09.2015 12:11, Tom Pfeifer napisał(a):
Janko Mihelić wrote on 2015-09-21 11:34:
There is amenity=arts_centre which is a subclass of
amenity=community_centre. It's used 11 688 times. So the cat's out of
the bag, why wouldn't you use youth_centre if we already use
art_centre?
These are different cases. The arts_centre is performance/exhibition
oriented and might have a small overlap with community_centre.
In my opinion overlap can be substantial (+ club=art and the likes). I
see that art is a common activity for people gathering together and
socializing. For now I see community centre as something between social
facility (help, care and socializing) and art club/art gallery/cultural
centre. Name is not enough to distinguish them in many cases.
The problem is also present with concert halls for example: this kind is
overlaping with theatre and general venues hall (convention center).
But another thing bothers me with youth_centre, and that is, what if
it is an arts_centre for youths?
Such "What if" questions appear rather hypothetical to me unless you
have real examples where there would be a conflict.
That's kind of question which is important exactly when crafting tagging
schemes. Otherwise you may end up mixing all the things together, giving
hard time to the mappers who want to tag the ground truth - for example
memorial=war_memorial (function) and memorial=stone (form).
--
"The train is always on time / The trick is to be ready to put your bags
down" [A. Cohen]
_______________________________________________
Tagging mailing list
[email protected]
https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/tagging
