On 22-Oct-16 08:07 PM, Martin Koppenhoefer wrote:
While it is true that hunting might be allowed or not in nature
reserves, and that according to the situation it might be necessary or
beneficial for the nature if some hunting with the aim of population
control is done, leisure=nature_reserve still is not the answer to the
question how to tag a hunting area (IMHO). You simply can't tell by
this tag if hunting is allowed or not.
Here some areas with the same key/value combinations allow hunting while
others do not. Without a specific tag hunting cannot be determined here.
I'd rather like to see a specific tag for hunting if hunting is what
you want to map.
The question could be: is this about a property of any area (hunting
allowed/forbidden/possible/encouraged/possible for a fee/whatever), or
is it an area specifically dedicated to hunting (main tag).
Why restrict the answer ..only to have to answer the other case later?
In case of a property, you could use "hunting=*", in case of a
dedicated area it could be something like amenity=hunting_area /
hunting_resort or similar.
For a already tagged feature or one that fits an existing case then
hunting=* would be 'good'.
For an area dedicated to the hunting of game then landuse=hunting would
be better than using amenity.
It is a use of the land. And any use of the land is an amenity to
someone, so it is more specific than the amenity key.
_______________________________________________
Tagging mailing list
[email protected]
https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/tagging
