I tend to ignore those validator messages from JOSM. We could invent stop_area_group, but then we would simply get different warnings.
When I make stop_area relations, I include everything that belongs together for one side of the road or that belongs to 1 platform in a bus station. Then I group those in a stop_area containing all those stop_area relations. If there is a bus station and a metro station next to a train station I have 3 such stop_area relations, which get group once again in a stop_area relation. The names don't necessarily correspond at the different levels. There might even be an airport included in the top level of the hierarchy, or a port terminal for ferries. Polyglot 2016-11-14 9:26 GMT+01:00 Tijmen Stam <[email protected]>: > > Dear all, > > > > > > The wiki page of public_transport=stop_area includes a sentence "For > > larger interchanges it is often appropriate to organise stop areas into a > > hierarchy. Heathrow Airport would for example consist of 5 terminals, a > > coach station and two underground stations with many associated > > facilities." but I don't know how to make the hierarchy. > > > > > > For example, in my town there is an interchange with a metro station with > > two platforms, light rail station with six platforms and two associated > > bus stations. Currently there are four stop_areas, one for metro station, > > one for light rail station, one for each bus station. How to make that > > hierarachy? > > I had seen the same sentence and wrestled with it as well. > Concider the central station of Amsterdam, which has one (soon: two) > subway stations with 2 platforms each, a bus station with 10-is platforms, > another bus station with 7 platforms, two tram stations with 4-5 > platforms each, and a ferry terminal with 5ish ferry slips, and off course > 12 train platforms (with a/b/c sections meaning about 30-ish stop > position/platform combinations) > > What I would do is make a stop area for each "substation" (for one mode) > then make a general stop area which contains only stop areas and maybe one > main station node. This gives warnings from the JOSM validator, as a > stop_area isn't an accepted member of a stop_area. > > > > _______________________________________________ > Tagging mailing list > [email protected] > https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/tagging >
_______________________________________________ Tagging mailing list [email protected] https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/tagging
