On 11/06/19 19:30, marc marc wrote:
Le 11.06.19 à 11:14, Tomas Straupis a écrit :What do you think?I find very strange that reservoir is a landuse by itself it would be a bit like putting landuse=rest on a bench or landuse=stop on a parking lot. landuse should be what the place is for. reservoir is the function of the object, which is inscribed when a larger purpose (agriculture, energy production, flood management,...)
Counter argument.. Reservoir is for the storage of water, thus a use of the land. It could be named 'water_storage' but the areas mapped would remain the same. Some reservoirs serve more than one end purpose e.g. flood management and water for human consumption.
natural=water is not perfect (soe dislike natural for man-made feature) but at least it allows to split "there is water" with its function
The key natural is also disliked by me. Water is a land cover .. so could be tagged landcover=water. Other features in the key natural are either land covers or land forms and could be split into those 2 keys. _______________________________________________ Tagging mailing list [email protected] https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/tagging
