Hello Frederik, Le 15.06.19 à 12:28, Frederik Ramm a écrit : > On 6/14/19 5:49 PM, marc marc wrote: >> I think the proposals for a new tag should clearly say: >> - add such tag >> - edit the old tag description to point the new tag >> - write to editors to adapt presets >> - propose a mecanical edit, if necessary by splitting it up >> to avoid a global opponent blocking everything >> - propose the depreciation of the old tag > > Such proposals would need to clear a much higher bar than we currently > have. I'm thinking "at least 500 votes of which 75% in favour" or so. > > You cannot have 15 people decide on such wide-ranging changes.
why does osmf let this be done permanently with fewer people? self-goal and wrong target ! tl;dr; I propose that you submit your idea to the vote, a vote that will obviously have to obtain the score you want to put forward. is your proposal simply disconnected from reality ? no recent proposal for tags has received so many voters/participants if I remember well, even ml tagging nor a call for discussion on the wiki does not receive so many participant. or do you want each proposal to be the subject of a massive emailing so that a larger number of people can participate ? it would be very interesting to have more people, yes. but beware of self-goal, right now, there are 5 ways to depreciate a tag - a proposal, submitted to collective intelligence, transparency, and voting. have about twenty participants - variant with mécanical edit. - a thematic operation as has already been done several times, collective discussion, transparent but with a reduced visibility, without a vote. public variable according to the themes, fatally smaller than a global discussion. - individual action of contributeur. one change A into B, another change B into A - a mass edition distributed and spread out via editor, not very transparent, subject to a "informal vote" between 1 to 5 dev avoid wrong target, making community deprecation impossible will only take action out of the control of the community. we know the consequences of this, avoid a self-goal ! Regards, Marc _______________________________________________ Tagging mailing list [email protected] https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/tagging
