Hi Michael, Thank you for such interesting links :) I was looking for established classification but most of time several properties are mixed in attributes which is less usable. My points below.
Le jeu. 19 mars 2020 à 05:01, Michael Patrick <geodes...@gmail.com> a écrit : > Since pumps have been a manufactured commodity for about 400 years ( > https://www.worldpumps.com/general-processing/features/a-brief-history-of-pumps/ > ) there is an abundance of existing typologies and taxonomies dealing with > pumps. If the goal is a general tagging scheme that can further be refined > when needed to more detailed descriptions, there is a fairly low delta from > a complete scheme compared to an incomplete one which will grow by random > accretion. See IEEE GlobalSpec's Engineering360 > https://www.globalspec.com/pfdetail/pumps/types > That sounds the most promising repository I could integrate to proposed pump=* values. Note that some proposed values already match this IEEE classification (Wikipedia may took inspiration there) > <https://www.globalspec.com/pfdetail/pumps/types> > There are public domain classification systems available also, like > *UNSPSC* # *4015151 *takes you to a Stainless Steel Deep Well > Submersible Pump. See the section " 2.2. Industrial Categorization > Schemes and Product Data Management in 'Inter-organizational Networks" in > Integrated > Product Ontologies for Inter-Organizational Networks' at > https://pdfs.semanticscholar.org/c471/40672c0c2e5a34c098fcd2809185537ee985.pdf > Main problem of "Stainless Steel Deep Well Submersible Pump." is such a name give many information, but let the mechanism unknown. We've got material=*, submersible=yes/no and eventually man_made=water_well but no corresponding value for pump=* I've got the same issue with European INSPIRE classes as well in other projects. Once solved, this would be useful to give more details about a given pump=* value in a further proposal. All the best François
_______________________________________________ Tagging mailing list Tagging@openstreetmap.org https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/tagging