May 23, 2020, 20:41 by kevin.b.ke...@gmail.com: > On Fri, May 22, 2020 at 4:31 AM Mateusz Konieczny via Tagging > <tagging@openstreetmap.org> wrote: > >> It is extremely rare - if there is single access road to a private residence >> then it is a driveway no matter whatever it is paved asphalt road or >> something that requires tractor to pass. >> >> Maybe it would matter in case where there is one road used as driveway and >> second road that may be used to access property but is unused, possibly due >> to >> poor state. >> >> But that would because one functions as driveway and one not. >> In case of people using worse-quality road as a driveway >> and not using better quality road as a driveway >> the tagging also should follow function and road used as driveway >> should be tagged as driveway. >> > > The case that I scratch my head over is a road whose primary purpose > is farming or forestry, but that is also the path of access to > someone's cabin. > OK, I agree that this one is tricky, and this case is more complicated. I limited my discussion to single use roads (either track or driveway), because I was trying to attack "something used solely as driveway but low quality may not be tagged as a driveway" what is clearly wrong. I forgot about this case where something is actually both driveway and both track. > You seem to be saying that the presence of a dwelling > trumps all other uses, but that doesn't make sense to me. Some of the > cabins on inholdings in the forests around here are accessed by ATV or > snowmobile, depending on the season, because the road has deteriorated > beyond what a typical SUV can handle. (No, they don't get Amazon > deliveries.) > This problem is just avoided by my formulation (or maybe holiday cabin still counts as a residence?). But in some cases you have one house or one isolated group of houses deep in a forest. In this case I would say that last stage (road connecting this dwelling to the forest track system) is highway=service, service=driveway, without downgrading entire forest track system to a driveway status. So maybe my claim should be "something used solely or primarily as a driveway is a driveway, no matter its physical characteristics (surface, lane count, smoothness, access, ownership). And therefore tagged as highway=service service=driveway" ? > I also don't want to say that a logging track is a > residential driveway just because there's one guy with a parcel > somewhere fifteen miles off the highway, when the only other traffic > on the track is International Paper's trucks. > >
_______________________________________________ Tagging mailing list Tagging@openstreetmap.org https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/tagging
