There lots of forest roads/path, where the bicycle/pushed carried is prohibited. Mostly, private owned land with a access_sign. “the bicycle” “transportation vehicle” is prohibited.
Because, navigation programs do not us bicycle=no, as a hard no, there is the need for a extra value. bicycle=explicit_no, means “the vehicle” is prohibited. Why a value? We need a one value, otherwise a lot of more keys, which makes it things complicated. At the end it means for all explicit no! bicycle_pushed=no motorcycle_pushed=no horse_pushed=no ;-) moped_pushed=no mofa_pushed=no etc. Better one value, key=explicit_no What do you think? If we do not solve this problem, this stays forever. On the wiki page dismount, this bicycle_pushed is mentioned. https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Tag:bicycle%3Ddismount For me a wrong advise. The problem is wider for more transportation modes, even for other product to carry around. Private access_sign rules, can go much further then traffic_sign. In what is prohibited. What the owner think and write down on the sign is valid. The skateboard is prohibited, means you can not carry a skateboard around with you. skateboard=explicit_no I need this value to do it correctly. Where the bicycle is no allowed. Or a other value meaning the same.
_______________________________________________ Tagging mailing list [email protected] https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/tagging
