17 Aug 2020, 07:36 by [email protected]:
> ***Ops: this feature is not currently subject to a vote. Wrong subject, sorry
> all. Current status is RFC.***
> Thank you for your welcome.
>
>
>
>> Is it just about signposted and officially recognized places?
>> Or is it supposed to be similar to tree_lined tag.
>>
>
> They are indeed signposted and officially recognized places.
>
Then it would be good idea to clearly
communicate this requirement in tags.
official_green_alley?
>
>
>> How mapper is supposed to distinguish
>> where it is done by local residents and one
>> where it is done by city?
>>
>
> Every green alley I know have been initiated by local residents, then have
> received some help by the city, but other cities have their own ways. Would
> this distinction be important?
>
Because if you introduce green_alley
tag with intention to use it only for
some green alleys then it will be confusing,
and tag will likely change meaning anyway.
See natural=tree originally intended
to be used only for notable trees.
>> Is it possible that such green alley will not include any plants?
>> If yes - name is confusing. If no - why mention this bonus equipment as
>> distinguishing feature.
>>
>
> No, plants are the central aspect of a green alley, but the various
> "furniture" is worth a mention, since the alley is also a kind of a
> collective achievement (not sure if the phrasing is good, I mean "oeuvre
> commune") where citizen fill the space with arts and furniture as they deem
> relevant. Like a park: a park is also, most of the time, tree-lined, but it
> can also include some public furniture that are worth mentioning if you try
> to describe the idea of a park to someone who never saw one.
>
> This concept might be new to many, but it is definitely something that is
> recognized by all who live nearby one, and officially signposted and
> recognized by the city in it's own maps. It would also be a useful thing to
> add to OSM, as many residents or outsiders look forward to them.
>
>
> Le dim. 16 août 2020 à 03:44, Mateusz Konieczny via Tagging <>
> [email protected]> > a écrit :
>
>> Thanks for posting on mailing list!
>>
>> Is it just about signposted and officially recognized places?
>> Or is it supposed to be similar to tree_lined tag.
>>
>> How mapper is supposed to distinguish
>> where it is done by local residents and one
>> where it is done by city?
>>
>> Why it is using alley=green_alley if
>> it is restricted only to some green alleys?
>>
>> "Some are public art places, furnished with benchs,
>> playgrounds for kids, tables, public bookcases or include urban gardening
>> spots."
>>
>> Is it possible that such green alley will not include any plants?
>> If yes - name is confusing. If no - why mention this bonus equipment as
>> distinguishing feature.
>>
>> Aug 16, 2020, 00:42 by >> [email protected]>> :
>>
>>> Hi all,
>>> I'd like to revive an old proposal, namely the ">>> Green alley>>> ".
>>> Description:
>>> A green alley is a service alley that a group of local residents embellish
>>> with vegetation, such as trees, vines and flowers. This collective effort
>>> results in a better quality of life for residents in addition to reduce the
>>> phenomenon of urban heat islands.
>>>
>>> Cities with a special program can support these renaturalization efforts by
>>> providing tools and special materials, or by performing special roadwork
>>> such as digging holes for plants and trees.
>>>
>>> Link to the wiki: >>>
>>> https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Proposed_features/green_alley
>>>
>>> Original discussion on tagging mailing list: >>>
>>> https://lists.openstreetmap.org/pipermail/tagging/2013-August/014514.html
>>>
>>> Cheers
>>>
>>
>> _______________________________________________
>> Tagging mailing list
>> >> [email protected]
>> >> https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/tagging
>>
_______________________________________________
Tagging mailing list
[email protected]
https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/tagging
