Vào lúc 07:54 2022-12-02, Tobias Knerr đã viết:
On 02.12.22 15:02 Mateusz Konieczny wrote:
If it is second case of preprocessing being impossible -
why do massive duplication and ask to duplicate ref value
AND name value AND highway value?
The duplication-free solution of referencing the road's way ID as
is_sidepath:of = w4087515 is going meet some resistance from people
pointing out the need for, and current lack of, editor support to make
such values usable.
To clarify, the proposal calls for is_sidepath:of=* to be set to a road
classification consistent with highway=*. It uses the combination of
is_sidepath:of=*, is_sidepath:of:name=*, and is_sidepath:of:ref=* to
unambiguously^H^H^H^H less ambiguously identify the nearby roadway. This
is similar to the street:name=* key that mappers in a few cities have
been using, but with the added benefit of resolving ambiguity when there
are similarly named streets running parallel. (Is this a big enough
problem to require the full set of tags?)
If the proposal had called for is_sidepath:of=* to refer to another way
by its ID, I think we'd be howling about how way IDs are unstable and
that we've reinvented relation membership, but in the inverse direction.
--
[email protected]
_______________________________________________
Tagging mailing list
[email protected]
https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/tagging
