Late to the conversation but......
First up, from people have said, what cc-cleaner is doing is shocking
vandalism, whether they intend it or not.
In a worst case scenario, all non-CT compliant information will be expunged on
1st April. There is no need to delete it (especially manually) before this
date. If it’s not being replaced there is absolutely no benefit in doing so.
Second up, while (quality) re-mapping is the bees knees of replacing non-CT
compliant data and I would consider it a preferred option, we’re never going to
re-map it all by 1st April. We might re-map most, with any luck, but not all.
Hence, we’re going to need some smart algorithms to deal with what’s left. Is
there a working group on this or a mailing list? Perhaps Richard W would know?
In my opinion I think Mark P.’s suggestion is good and something similar to
that would be what ends up happening
I also think there is a need for stepped approach, combining algorithms with
re-mapping. A first pass algorithm to clear the map of trivial edits would make
re-mapping a lot easier. The bot-added maxspeed tags colour an awful lot of the
map light red.
There also needs to be a central clearing point – a mailing list or wiki – to
either contribute locations that need re-mapping or to volunteer to re-map some.
Regards
El Segundo can’t win
_______________________________________________
Talk-au mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/talk-au
