I tried to create a "Bicentennial National Trail" relation, but found 4
relations of this name:
Relation 176684: created in July 2009 by John Henderson with route=hiking. This
covers 213km from Canberra CBD to Taralga (half way between Canberra and Sydney)
Relation 2347837 created on 13/8/2012 by Nick Barker with route=hiking. This
covers about 95% of VIC section, 40% of Canberra section, 2% of NSW section, 1%
of QLD section. Total 715km of which 53km of the Dargo High Plains Road is not
part of the BNT
Relation 2347838 created on 13/8/2012 by Nick Barker with route=bicycle. This
is almost the same as Relation 2347837 (with less ways and without the 53km of
Dargo High Plains Road). Total 645km.
Relation 2347839 created on 13/8/2012 by Nick Barker with route=mtb. This is
the same as Relation 2347838.
Question for Nick Barker: Why 3 relations? BNT is a trail for walkers, MTBers,
and horses, so these 3 relation will be the same.
Question for John Henderson and everybody: what should be the route type
(route=hiking, bicycle or mtb) when the trail is for walkers, MTBers and
horses?
I suggest:
1. Relation 2347837: to be renamed as Bicentennial National Trail - VIC
section; and remove sections in other states
2. Relation 2347838: to be renamed as Bicentennial National Trail - NSW
section; remove sections in other states; and merge with Relation 176684
3. Relation 2347839: to be renamed as Bicentennial National Trail - QLD
section; and remove sections in other states
4. Relation 176684: remove all sections; put Relations 2347837, 2347838,
2347839 into it as members; ie this relation will become a super-relation with
3 relations as member
5. Change all 4 relations to have tags: route=mtb, foot=yes and horse=yes
IMHO, this is becasue 1) BNT is for road bikes, 2) trails for hiking may not
allow MTB, 3) 99.9% of trails that allow MTB also allow walkers, 4) it allows
the tags "mtb:difficulty=advanced, and mtb:type=crosscountry as in now Relation
2347838
John Henderson, you won't be able to see the trail at
hiking.waymarkedtrails.org, but it will be at mtb.waymarkedtrails.org.
Any comments? or I'll do it.
Mander
_______________________________________________
Talk-au mailing list
[email protected]
https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/talk-au
