Hi all, I see Sebastian has posted to the list now
background to this: Way History: 679145843
about a year ago Sebastian had bicycle=no, highway=track
as part of the DWG sanctioned revert I deleted the bicycle=no
Hi Sebastian
a bit more,
If I wanted to add tags I would go on site have a look and do
Mapillary photos. Unless there were already good photos. What I see
now is a construction site at the south end with gates I think. Its a
temporary construction track maybe and closed off now? No good photos
at the north end.
Going out on site and taking photos is time consuming but I think the
map is maturing, its moved to needing quality rather than quantity.
Also I want to back off slightly on my previous "tag it private if you
know it is private, don't guess" You can guess a little bit but you
still need to be fairly sure.
Tony
Yep no problem. I hadn?t realised I had replied privately. Will
reply to the list.
regards,
Sebastian
On 26 Mar 2022, at 9:39 pm, fors...@ozonline.com.au wrote:
?Hi
A quick reply now, its late, and maybe more considered tomorrow
its tagged highway=track
I can see no "access all=yes" so nothing is being asserted about the access
that suits me for now as I know nothing about the track
I think I can see a gate or fence, not sure,
38°11?52?S, 145°8?22?E
-38.1976644, 145.1393379
and maybe the other end
38°12?12?S, 145°8?3?E
-38.2032271, 145.1342893
When I load a map file on my gps unit it will show this way as
accessible for me to ride based on the OSM tagging. Unless there
is an explicitly tag bike=no, private or similar then it?s will
still think that I can legally ride on it.
I don't know if you can legally ride on it or not. I doubt that
through traffic is treated differently to local, you are probably
either allowed in or not. I doubt bikes are treated differently
I have replied privately because you have asked privately, this
stuff is OK for the list and you would get some more and probably
better ideas.
in summary
If there are gates then your gps problem is solved
no bike= tag is called for, bikes are probably the same as cars
tag it private if you know it is private, don't guess
If your GPS wants to send you that way its not necessarily a fault
with the map
Are you happy to put this on the list?
Tony
_______________________________________________
Talk-au mailing list
Talk-au@openstreetmap.org
https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/talk-au
