2011/3/15 Jaak Laineste <[email protected]>: > Hi Rich, > >> i'm resending this message after subscribing to this list. in addition to >> the issues below i'd like to report my email being ignored by moderator ;) > > This is my mistake. The list bouncing list has tens of spam emails > each week, yours is probably all times second or third one which was > actually not spam. Therefore these get easily overlooked. I try to > review bounce list once a week or two. > >> 1. http://www.openstreetmap.org/browse/way/100339092/history >> >> a) it is overlapping 3 times; >> b) it is not connected to other ways; >> c) there are no uploaded traces to confirm existence of such a feature; >> d) my trace from yesterday and other uploaded traces seem to cross it in a >> straight line :) >> >> a such this is highly suspect :) > > This roundabout should be there. For Estonia we have permission from > National Land Board (Maaamet) to use their WMS maps and detailed > aerials. These should be listed in JOSM WMS/TMS plugins also. If not, > then there are instructions in > http://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Et:Beginners_Guide_1.1.2 which has > WMS URL. Their aerials can be several years old, and city streets are > rebuilt each year, so cannot trust them really 100%. But in this case > it seems that the info matches with aerials at least. Of course > technically it must be connected to other ways. > I checked today with one of the local people and they say there is a roundabout but it is somewhat "virtual" :) it is painted on the street and right now there is no way to see it. But still there are 3 circles which has to be corrected, thnx.
>> 2. http://www.openstreetmap.org/browse/way/100350809/history >> >> a) overlaps the other street; >> b) one attached way not attached on the other end; >> c) no uploaded traces that confirm its existence >> >> also quite suspect (and i guess xybot already fixed it a bit). > > I compared with aerial, and did not really match with it. But last > time when I was driving somewhere around this area last summer I > remember major constructions, so aerials are most probably outdated. > Tags/node issues can be of course wrong just accidentally. I can confirm the constructions and plans for roundabout. > >> 3. http://www.openstreetmap.org/browse/way/26252364/history >> >> a) added area=yes to a non-area street; >> b) added lots of other, redundant tags. and possibly some incorrect ones as >> well. > > You are correct, these seem to be technical errors. Feel free to fix > them, and/or send PM to the editor. He/she seems to be quite new to > OSM, so perhaps just accidents. If you use some template-based editor > (potlatch2, josm) which has fields for all the parameters, then > over-cautious editor may try to actually fill all of them. > > -- > Jaak Laineste > > _______________________________________________ > Talk-ee mailing list > [email protected] > http://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/talk-ee > -- A. Kaaber _______________________________________________ Talk-ee mailing list [email protected] http://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/talk-ee
