On Fri, 12 Dec 2008, Peter Miller wrote:

> I have been working on adding wiki pages for every County and Unitary
> Authority in the UK (there are 140 in total) so that we have a
> consistent place to add this sort of information. There were articles
> for some and there are about 19 added so far. Could people add county
> pages for their areas and and use this for a hit-list section of
> wanted places?:
> http://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Category:County_in_England

Just a thought, but UK != England - might it be an idea to rename this 
page, or is the plan to create separate pages for Wales, Scotland, 
Northern Ireland...?

> Do remember that the local councils might be interested themselves.
> There is growing official awareness that OSM exists and might be
> useful to them. That is one reason why I am building the local
> authority pages.

I'm not sure why the councils would use OSM - as far as I know the 
councils' internal systems (e.g. highways department, etc) are heavilly 
based on OS maps with the council's own layers overlaid.  This means (as I 
interpret it):

1. The council's own layers are derived from OS maps so could never be 
integrated with OSM
2. Since the councils have to publish their maps they presumably already 
have a licence from OS to do so, so using OSM *as well* won't save them 
money.
3. Like it or not, OS maps are usually more detailed than OSM - most 
(all?) areas in OSM don't map detail like where the running lanes of a 
road end and the walkway begins and few areas have individual buildings 
mapped.  For example, zoom into some of the residential streets on: 
http://maps.swansea.gov.uk/localview/OnTheMap.aspx

I'd be pretty interested to hear another side to the argument though. :)

  - Steve
    xmpp:[email protected]   sip:[email protected]   http://www.nexusuk.org/

      Servatis a periculum, servatis a maleficum - Whisper, Evanescence


_______________________________________________
Talk-GB mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/talk-gb

Reply via email to