> However, Hampshire (England) is not rendering. I have looked at
> the
> data with various tools and can't see what is wrong.
> 
> The best tool for finding errors in boundaries is this one, but
> it
> fails for Hamphire for some reason:-
> http://osm.cdauth.de/route-manager/relation.php?id=76228

It seems to fail for Essex as well, and I'm fairly sure that is OK,
so I suspect the tool has problems (though perhaps a sample of two
relations is insufficient).

I suspect (as I managed to email direct), that the problem is
related to the pink way on the geofabrik page which it says is
always an error. That way was tagged as both boundary=administrative
and natural=coastline and the nearby ones I checked are only tagged
as natural=coastline; as the way is in three different levels of
administrative boundary I removed the tags from the way itself.
(Note to Chris Hill, it is (or should be) fine if boundary relations
follow non boundary ways if for example the boundary does actually
follow the middle of a road or river).

I don't know how often geofabrik update their data, but as far as I
can see the boundary itself is fine, as evidenced by all the links
you sent where it looks OK, but to see whether it was just the pink
way upsetting it will probably take until after their next update.

Ed



_______________________________________________
Talk-GB mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/talk-gb

Reply via email to