The lack of public right of way information is disappointing - but it is within OSM's capabilities to walk and map it. However, the lack of field boundary information is a serious deficiency as these are invaluable in practice to walkers attempting to plan, navigate, record and publish walks - especially in the more lowland and more farmed areas. Without the OS's right to enter onto private land without any advance permission, OSM mappers will remain seriously hampered in any attempt to map field boundaries. Hedges may be visible in good quality satellite or aerial photography but fences (and especially electric fences) will be very difficult.

Having said that, Nick's idea sounds good - probably "as good as it gets" with the present availability of data. I don't have the relevant IT skills but certainly support the concept!

mikh43

On 04/04/2010 11:34, Nick Whitelegg wrote:
Despite being disappointed at the lack of public right of way/field boundary info in the OS releases, I have to admit that VectorMap District does *look* very nice, kind of like Landranger minus contours and footpaths.

So I'm wondering, would it be possible to create maps which combine the VectorMap District raster layer with footpaths from OSM and contours from SRTM (or even the OS's own contour data, if that's better than SRTM?)

Would be a bit tricky but I'm wondering if the relevant colours in the VectorMap District (white, and the green colour used for woods) could be defined as transparent. A contour layer could then be defined as the bottom layer, then overlaid by a processed (to define transparency, as above) VectorMap District layer, then on top, overlaid with rights of way data from OSM - and then you'd kind of have an OpenLandranger map, perhaps. Might this work I wonder?

Nick


_______________________________________________
Talk-GB mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/talk-gb

--
*/Mike Harris/*
_______________________________________________
Talk-GB mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/talk-gb

Reply via email to