Ah, okay, then it would be better to stick with a dedicated GPS unit
like the Garmin eTrex 20.
Smartphones as they are right now are dang painful, yes, there are a few
conveniences, but the crazy pure touch scenario doesn't mostly work as
advertised, oh, how I miss the Blackberry (pre-touch) devices.
~Mayuresh
On 2015-07-23 05:13 PM, Sunil K wrote:
Mayuresh,
I didn't say the model you suggested is not accurate. The model I
had was not accurate(this is in 2010). If the reviews in amzon &
other place say it is accurate go for it.
I know Moto G is good,very fast to lock even in somewhat indoor, error
is less but less straight line stability than samsung . I mean if you
go in a car straight but with MOTO you get zig-zagged line (error is
3-4 m only).
I tried Moto E gps(1 st generation) earlier, for a small test only, it
was slow to lock. I am not sure about second generation.
I also don't use any smart phone (I use a tablet only for navigation
and osm mapping).
Regards
Sunil
On 07/23/2015 04:58 PM, Mayuresh Kathe wrote:
Hello Sunil,
If, as per what you're saying, the dedicated GPS units aren't as
accurate as the GPS modules found on cell phones, then it would
make better sense to invest in a cell phone.
You've suggested the Moto G; may I solicit your (and others)
opinion about the Moto E 2nd Gen? Reason being it's smaller and
easier to handle than the Moto G.
I anyways need to exit the old world of feature phones and enter
the bold new world of smartphones. :-)
Thanks,
~Mayuresh
On 2015-07-23 03:32 PM, Sunil K wrote:
Dear Mayuresh, I used a Garmin device in 2010 I don't remember
its model(it cost me 100 euro, but the accuracy was less). But it
have a gpx logging feature. Resultant gpx can be copied to
computer via usb, then josm to upload.
There are 2-3 things to look for 1. easy to enter POIs (may be
voice recording), is most important 2. ability to use OSM maps
(There was a way to convert OSM maps to garmin format), because
if the map is already there no need to again map it.
3. Is the accuracy() If these are there, then this device is ok.
Checkout Columbus V990 suggested by Paramvir (It have voice
recording feature)
I know one guy who uses modified osmtracker+ bt headset with
voice cancellation to capture POIs on a Moto G.
I use a samsung galaxy tab 7+ which is much more accurate the
garmin I had (but usually no harsh terrain, except my daughter,
it survived with colorful lines on screen)
Hope others also give there experiences.
Regards Sunil
Regards Sunil
On 07/23/2015 02:55 PM, Mayuresh Kathe wrote:
Hi Sunil,
Thanks for the response.
I would prefer to go for a standalone GPS unit like the Garmin
eTrex 20 because I can use it under any weather conditions
(which can get difficult with a smartphone).
While living in Uran, my primary task would be to perform
mapping activities during the three seasons which present
themselves as harsh environmental conditions, i.e. extreme
heat, heavy rains and bitter winters (no snow though).
So, suppose if I purchase the Garmin eTrex 20 and use it for
logging data, would there be any way to; 1. move data off the
unit and onto my Chromebook via USB? 2. convert the acquired
data to be usable with OSM? 3. easily upload that data to OSM?
Basically, since there are just a few local apps under a
Chromebook, would there be any web service which can convert
the data acquired from the GPS unit to the one which is
accepted by OSM?
Thanks,
~Mayuresh
On 2015-07-23 02:42 PM, Sunil K wrote:
Dear Mayuresh,
I would suggest to go for samsung tablet, or Moto G than
going for a standalone GPS like Garmin or TomTom( because
cost vs accuracy is better in the case of former, based on my
experiance from 2010 now it may be different). I dont know
how good is bluetooth or USB connected GPS (which can be
connected to your chromebook directly)
The only important think is GPS should be able to lock
without 2G or 3G network, in a remote location sometimes this
is crucial. Another think is battery life with GPS(with and
without screen on).
You could use apps like osmtracker to get gpx trail and way
points, Navit or OsmAnd(could also be used for tracking) for
existing map. There is a OSM editor vespucci but I don't know
how good it is.
br Sunil
On 07/23/2015 01:18 PM, Mayuresh Kathe wrote:
Hello,
I tried to keep this off list as much as I could, but it
would be improper to harangue just one person with newbie
type questions. :-)
I am basically from Mumbai, but also have a certain amount
of presence in a nearby hamlet called Uran (65Kms south
east of Mumbai).
I checked out the map for that region on OSM and found
very few details.
Given the fact that I would be spending a month there, once
in every 2 months (making it around 4 months a year), I
would like to invest time in helping map that region.
I have been advised to take a look at "JOSM" as an editor,
but found "iD" to be a lot better for my current situation,
i.e. only portable is a Google Chromebook.
I solicit advice on the GPS equipment I would need (I don't
use a smartphone).
Would you be kind enough to recommend a decent, low-cost
GPS unit for acquiring data which can be easily used with
OSM?
Thanks,
~Mayuresh
_______________________________________________
Talk-in mailing list
[email protected]
https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/talk-in
