This is an even better idea to have all this automated. I was exactly thinking this yesterday to put a tag in the relation stating the status of the progress and/or maybe even some kind of a quality value?
In a new version it would maybe great to have some more information. As I see this is a list just out of the relation. Is it possible to get some information in the list out of the ways, too? Like fixme, source etc? This would be a great tool for finding and fixing problems. The solutions given for quality assurance are not as good. Because there are millions of "possible" errors shown and I feel everytime like knocked out when looking at it and don't really feel like going on and fixing this things. I really think it is not helpful to have errors like "maxspeed=35 seems an unusual value" shown - what the heck?! The road sign states it like this... I think it is more helpful to know from the human user who exactly knows my GPS track was crappy it really would be a good idea to resurvey this... Great idea and maybe we can somehow combine all this and I really like the idea of the possibility to access the data directly. Maybe you can implement some kind of an search tool that let's me directly search in the data. Or at least choose the ways in a special area. Would be great. I forgot a lot on PHP programming in the last years - maybe I should start again... Christoph On 22.01.2010 02:16, Ævar Arnfjörð Bjarmason wrote: > On Thu, Jan 21, 2010 at 21:11, Christoph L. Hess > <[email protected]> wrote: >> I put up another site for the Icelandic road system on the OSM-wiki. >> Plan is maybe to get the list filled with information on the progress on >> the OSM map. I think it is better to have this on the OSM site then on >> the Icelandic Wikipedia. >> >> You can just add a percentage value by editing the site and edit the >> number after the words icelandroadprogress|100. Values between 0 to 100 >> are OK. All roads are at 0% now. It looks quite red now, but I think >> there are a lot of ways already on OSM, so the list should be getting >> green soon. >> >> http://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Icelandic_road_system >> >> Feel free to use it, but you don't have to, but hopefully this site is >> maintained more often and better than the Listi yfir þjóðvegi. >> >> Any comments and suggestions to improve this would be helpful. > > That's some great work, but the reason I for one stopped editing this > list on the wiki is because I felt silly maintaining something > manually that really should be done automatically. > > Here's an automatically generated list I just made: > http://openstreetmap.is/status/highways > > It looks bad now but I think this is a much better way to go about it. > Right now it only lists data about the relations and their tags but > I'll add something to analyze the data about the relation members too > so you can tell e.g. if the way ref=* and name=* values do not match > the relation values. > > I'll also go over the official Vegaskrá in generating that list to > list the things we don't have too. > > If we add something to the data itself saying whether a road is > complete, e.g. complete=yes on the relation we have all the data there > to autogenerate what we're manually maintaining right now. > > _______________________________________________ > Talk-is mailing list > [email protected] > http://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/talk-is _______________________________________________ Talk-is mailing list [email protected] http://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/talk-is
