A follow-up. Where did you get the Cagayan boundaries? The relation you added for Claveria <http://www.openstreetmap.org/browse/relation/1513450> and Santa Praxedes <http://www.openstreetmap.org/browse/relation/1513446> are wrong since the town center of Claveria <http://osm.org/go/42wXlrw2--> has been included within Santa Praxedes' boundary relation.
On Sun, Mar 27, 2011 at 10:14 PM, Eugene Alvin Villar <[email protected]> wrote: > Hi Ian, > > Well, I've been monitoring your edits and have fixed most of the > errors though not the omissions. :-) > > Some notable errors that I fixed: > 1. Batanes is not part of Cagayan. I've removed Batanes from the > Cagayan relation but I didn't create the Batanes relation. > 2. Siquijor is not part of Cebu. I've removed Siquijor from the Cebu > relation and marked the coastline of Siquijor as its own boundary > since there are no other visible islands of Siquijor (I think) such > that a relation is needed. > 3. Mapun (Cagayan de Tawi-Tawi) is not part of Palawan. I've removed > the municipality's islands from the Palawan relation. They (and the > Turtle Islands) have yet to be included in the Tawi-Tawi relation. > 4. When you moved the QC-Rizal boundary to Marikina River (which I'm > not sure is really correct), you created a duplicate river centerline. > I've fixed that, though research is needed to correctly determine if > the boundary is indeed on the Marikina River. > 5. Davao City is not part of Davao del Sur (though they're often > grouped together). > 6. Zamboanga City is not part of Zamboanga Sibugay. > > One major error that is yet to be fixed is that Dinagat Islands is no > longer a province since the law that created it was struck down by the > Supreme Court as unconstitutional. So the islands revert back to > Surigao del Norte. > > Regarding #5 and #6 above, I think that highly-urbanized cities (like > Baguio) and independent cities (like Cotabato) should be considered > outside the province admin boundary relations since these cities are > completely independent of any province administratively. But until we > have accurate city/municipal boundaries, I guess the current situation > can exist. Davao City and Zamboanga City (aside from Metro Manila > cities) are the current exceptions since they already have available > boundaries. > > As for the Cavite boundaries, they're very crude especially in the > southwestern half, but I guess they can be improved in the future. > > BTW, it seems that some of your admin relation edits is just > rearrangement of the ways so that they're in order? While this is > nice, it's not necessary since all the renderers that I know of can > handle out-of-order ways. > > On your PS: I think you're also signed up using another address: > haylockid at gmail.com? > > Eugene > > > On Sun, Mar 27, 2011 at 9:39 PM, Ian Haylock <[email protected]> wrote: >> Hi, >> >> Just finished creating relations for all the provinces. >> >> To answer Mannings email. >> >> Well done you found one of my deliberate mistakes :-) >> >> Actually I have no real idea which islands belong to which provinces. Feel >> free to move them from one relation to another. >> >> Sulu, and Palawan Provinces probably have some errors, as there are just so >> many islands. >> >> Some islands are also missing from the relations, those that I missed, which >> shouldn't be many, and those that are just a single node. feel free to add >> them. >> >> Also converted the admin areas in Mindano to relations. This is Seav's area >> I think. So worth checking they're correct. >> >> Also fixed a lot of broken boundaries in Manila, still some to go yet though. >> >> Added the municipalities for Cavite just so I could add the barangay that I >> live in, so that searching for my street would work. After 4 1/2 years I >> discover I live in Mambog, not Molino. Still at least the mail still arrives >> :-) >> >> Does anyone know of a source of municipalities that we could use ? Any >> reasonable maps would do. >> >> Cheers, Ian >> >> P.S. why did I have to sign up to this talk list again ? >> > -- http://vaes9.codedgraphic.com _______________________________________________ talk-ph mailing list [email protected] http://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/talk-ph
