Karl Newman [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote >Sent: 22 December 2007 6:02 AM >To: Andy Robinson >Cc: David James; [email protected] >Subject: Re: [OSM-talk] Featured images for christmas week > >On Dec 21, 2007 6:43 PM, Andy Robinson <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> >wrote: >> >> We thrashed out ideas on th wiki the other day and decided upon the >following: >> >> The buiding areas are tagged with building=residential (or >> building=whatever if its something else) >> >> The nodes are also tagged with buidling=residential and have an >> additional ref=# on them for the house number. >> >> Will document this in Map Features if it looks to work out ok once >rendered. >> >> Cheers >> >> Andy >> -- >> Andy Robinson >> > >Okay, that will work for numbering buildings and showing the number on >a map. The argument I'm having on the Wiki is more for house numbering >which can be used for address interpolation along a street. GPS >devices use this sort of numbering (which is my intended application). >
Yes, its something I've noted that the house numbers are often too close to more than one street to be sure which street they belong to on a proximity basis. If the nodes are always within a building area then that area in the majority of cases can be linked to its street through proximity. There are however some exceptions, especially buildings which bound more than one road. So it would be necessary to add specific information to either the building or the node to identify the street in these cases but it should be possible to get to the majority of locations without adding a pile of extra tags. Beyond that it should be possible to use a proximity basis for all other data (town, region etc). There is also the issue of whether every property number is required. I find that when using off-the-shelf navigation products they can generally take me to the end of the correct drive. But I find I'm driving so slowly by that point I could have worked it out anyway. So do we really need every unique address? Probably not. For the vast majority of cases an interpolation between the start and end number on a continuous run of property (whether odd, even or mixed) should be enough to work out the intermediate properties with sufficient accuracy for routing. Oddball properties or properties with names alone will be in the database individually anyway. Of course if the unique postal_code is added to a node or area that gives an extra method for location resolution potential. Cheers Andy _______________________________________________ talk mailing list [email protected] http://lists.openstreetmap.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/talk

