Am Montag 30 März 2009 schrieb Ulf Lamping: > Guenther Meyer schrieb: > > Am Montag 30 März 2009 schrieb Adrian Moisey: > >> Hi > >> > >>>>> Someone else started a proposal for a gym, I need it in my area. So > >>>>> I'm finishing it off: > >>>>> http://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Proposed_features/Gym > >>>> > >>>> Why not simply use: > >>>> > >>>> leisure=sports_centre > >>>> sport=work_out (or gymnastics or ...) > >>>> > >>>> Regards, ULFL > >>> > >>> wh have a key for sports facilites, so why not sport=gym? > >> > >> There are no tags for 'sport=work-out' or 'sport=gym'. > >> Also, a Gym isn't a sports_centre, its an actual building designed for > >> Gymning. > > > > right. so you have to create a new one. > > as most gyms are not part of a sports centre, tagging > > leisure=sports_centre for every gym would be wrong. > > > > a gym is used for physical workout, so sport is better suited than > > amenity. sport=gym (only this, whithout leisure=...) says everything > > needed to basically describe and categorize this facilities, so it should > > be better than amenity=gym. > > No one is talking about amenity here! :-) > the proposal this thread was started for reads amenity=gym: http://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Proposed_features/Gym
> The current logic is: > > 1.) leisure=xy for the facility (stadium, pitch, sports_centre, > golf_course, ...) > > 2.) sport=xy for the actual sport done here > > > I don't think we need different leisure tags for tennis_halls, > boxing_clubs, ... when we already have a working solution. > no one was talking of different leisure tags... > The advantage of the current system is the renderers not interested in > showing different kinds of sports_centres can simply render only this > tag generically and ignoring the sport tag altogether - at least all > facilities will then show up on the map in question. > the same would be possible for the key sport. every element containing the key sport could be drawn with a generic sport-icon, if the renderer is not interested in further specification. a sports centre for me is a place, where multiple sports facilites are combined in a building or area, and not every gym/tennis hall/whatever is built in this way. so if something is not a sports centre it should not be tagged as such. if your "logic" says to do this anyhow, this is simple wrong.
signature.asc
Description: This is a digitally signed message part.
_______________________________________________ talk mailing list [email protected] http://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/talk
