On Tue, 11 Aug 2009, Alex L. Mauer wrote: > OK, but how does that mean it was "forced"? No one was (or is) held at > gunpoint and ordered to use highway=path. We followed the standard, > documented procedure for adding a tag to the wiki. We did nothing > nefarious to stuff the votes (at least I didn't, and I am not aware of > any sock-puppets or anything like that) > > I don't even know where the idea of needing a mandate[1] comes in. No > one's being elected to represent someone else. There are no policies > that some hypothetical person who would have been elected could have > made public. And no goverment(!?) is trying to implement a policy here. > So, uh... what? > > -Alex Mauer "hawke"
I was not making a personal attack. I am looking at the "rules" and I find that neither justice nor good decision making is necessary with the rules as they stand. I am talking about making sure that changes are deliberated by a broader church than current procedure demands. As far as you are concerned you followed the rules. However, by following those rules to the letter, you have actually been party to a fairly big split. Here it's winter, the nights are long and I have time to read the wiki and mailing lists. When its summer I won't be, I'll be out mapping and having a lot more fun. So the next contentious issue you wish to get through, do it in my summer, so I don't notice until late in winter. _______________________________________________ talk mailing list [email protected] http://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/talk

