Martin Koppenhoefer wrote: > 2009/8/13 Nop <[email protected]>: >> Proposal #2: Introduce offical dedication >> Leave old tags as they are and accept that foot/cycleway and designated >> are as fuzzy as described above. Clarify that these tags only give >> information on possible use, but not about the legal situation. >> Introduce a new tag biclyce/foot=official to tag the strict use case of >> road-signed ways or corresponding legal dedication. >> >> This way, nothing needs to be changed in existing fuzzy tagging, but >> real foot/cycleways are simply tagged by adding an "official" or >> changing designated to official if appropriate. > > IMHO if this solution is chosen we should also deprecate "designated", > as it is of no more use, and would just lead to possible problems when > contradictory to official.
I appreciate Nop's proposal - but why replace "designated" by "official"? I do not see that "designated" has been used in the past with a meaning differing from what "official" would be used for in future. Or did I miss anything in this discussion? Hatto _______________________________________________ talk mailing list [email protected] http://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/talk

