2009/8/22 John Smith <[email protected]>: > --- On Sat, 22/8/09, Morten Kjeldgaard <[email protected]> wrote: > >> Not really. There's a lot of elevation data available in the GPS traces, and >> since roads where incline=* is relevant are drawn along GPS traces, it's a >> matter of exploiting that data value. I'm aware that the GPS elevation data >> isn't terribly accurate on an absolute scale, but when determining inclines >> we will be making elevation differences which will decrease the error >> significantly. > > I doubt most GPS traces would be useful for this kind of thing, most vertical > GPS data is +/- 10m under the best possible conditions, usually I seem to be > +/- 20m most of the time, and it's not a stable 20m diff it jumps about just > like GPS positions do. > > You'd need a GPS with an altimeter, or a stand alone altimeter, to do this > kind of elevation differences to get accuracy better than up/down.
+1. E.g. the widespread 60 CSx from a well known manufacturer offers this, but (I guess) almost noone does a calibration before every log (at least I almost never do). That's why absolute elevation is not reliable, but the relative data (i.e. difference from one junction to another) is still "high"precision compared to GPS-elevation. I wonder if some smart programmer could use this in some way for OSM. Provided you have some reliable height-points, e.g. from public survey, mountain-tops, other official signs, you could use this relative data to calculate also the intermediate nodes. cheers, Martin _______________________________________________ talk mailing list [email protected] http://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/talk

