I was doing an overpass query for place=continent and noticed that we do not have Oceania but Australia with this note:

"Note that Oceania, which is a more common designation in some countries, is actually based on a different continental classification system to the one OSM uses. So please translate Australia as Australia, not as Oceania"

However looking at what is within is_in:continent="Australia" then I only get regions and cities and no countries. is_in:continent="Oceania" gives me the normal countries we think of as Oceania (including Australia the country).

Thus it seems place=continent;name="Australia" is now outdated and not used. According to usage it seems clear that we are now using the regular Oceania classification.

I propose we change this to reflect to current usage.

--Jóhannes / Stalfur

_______________________________________________
talk mailing list
[email protected]
https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/talk

Reply via email to