<anton>You have labeled Tango "classic tango". To me there is Tango or non Tango. </anton>
Anton: Defining the dance strictly by the music creates a very slippery slope. Tell me - what is tango? Is it only OT Victor and the Old Guard? Does it move forward in time to D'Arienzo (who still played a lot of 2/4 time just as did the old guard)? What about the Golden Age orchestras that played primarily in 4/4 rather than 2/4? Perhaps tango only means Old Guard and Golden Age? What about D'Arienzo of the '50s? Or later years DiSarli. On what day did they quit playing tango and start playing non-tango? Piazzolla was a bandoneon player in Troilo's orchestra. Did he play tango when he played with Triolo? And on what day did Piazzolla quit playing tango? Etc. I don't get black and white. _______________________________________________ Tango-L mailing list [email protected] http://mailman.mit.edu/mailman/listinfo/tango-l
