Hello Subscribers,
I really don't understand this antipathy toward the 8CB. Many posts on this thread and others (e.g. Why teachers use the (D)8CB(WBS) (15 Apr 2003 ), Breaking the "paso basico (12 Feb 2008)) express a visceral disgust for the 8CB that mystifies me. The consensus opinion of these posts seems to be that the 8CB is an overlearned pattern with a primacy effect that makes it difficult to overcome. Let me tell you what I think the 8CB is supposed to be (as I did on a recent thread), and then I'll return to this point about getting away from it. I have been doing partner dancing for over 20 years covering such dances as swing, salsa, waltz, samba, quick step, foxtrot, hustle, cha cha, rumba, bolero, nightclub two-step, besides tango. I have never heard any instructor in any of the hundreds of classes I've taken say that you must commit the basic step to memory as a pattern. The basic step for any dance is taught as a way to learn and practice the elemental moves of the dance. That's it! On occasion, I have heard professional dancers say that they use the basic step during their rehearsals a warm-up. So yes, the basic step may be overlearned, but that's good! Basic steps are not necessarily easy; they are just elemental. So if one cannot do the basic step(s) well, one probably cannot dance the dance well. The 8CB in tango is useful for several reasons. As I said in a previous post, the 8CB is the only pattern in A. tango I know of that has assigned counts. These counts are used to identify the landmark positions (e.g. 3 and 5) in much the same way as ballet positions are numbered. I know I'm not the only one who has heard a tango instructor say, "Alright, everybody get into 5!" In fact, I've heard this kind of phrase used on numerous occasions by different instructors. If one does not know what "5" means, one is lost. Another valuable use of the 8CB is that one may assume that everyone doing the dance has at least some knowledge of it. So when I'm dancing with a new, unfamiliar partner, I almost always start the dance with a version of the 8CB just to gage her level. Once I do that, I rarely return to it; at least I know where we stand. Now about breaking away from the 8CB. First, let me say that whatever pattern is learned first probably will be overused. That is the primacy effect. As a beginner who initially learns ochos or walking will almost certainly be an ocho or walking freak. The obvious reason is that with a limited dance vocabulary one can do only what one knows. The point is that the 8CB is not the bad guy. This inference suggests the key to breaking away from whatever one's trying to break away from: increase the dance vocabulary. So by learning more moves, one will rely less on the initial pattern. This process may not be easy, but it is the only way I know to achieve dance proficiency. Bob ________________________________________________________________________ More new features than ever. Check out the new AIM(R) Mail ! - http://webmail.aim.com _______________________________________________ Tango-L mailing list [email protected] http://mailman.mit.edu/mailman/listinfo/tango-l
