Sveiki,

Sunday, July 24, 2011, 2:12:41 PM, you wrote:

> Hi Vilius

> Sunday, July 24, 2011, 9:27:21 AM, Tbbeta wrote:

>> Sveiki,

>> Saturday, July 23, 2011, 11:42:20 PM, you wrote:

>>> [+] (#0008351) When The Bat! completes all IMAP tasks, it selects
>>> INBOX and idles in this folder, to be able to receive notifications
>>> about new messages before refreshing all the folders

>> This  should  IDLE on the mailbox which is currently selected. Because
>> mail  can arrive on ANY mailbox if server side filtering is configured
>> for example.

> I think this should be configurable. Most people running IMAP don't
> have server side filters running, so a global sync at startup and
> then monitor INBOX is what they need.

> A few "power users" (a) have access to setup server side filtering
> and (b) have the knowledge to do it. For these people having the
> option to IDLE in the currently selected folder.

> What do you think?

Yes  it  could  be  configurable.  However  it should default to current
mailbox.

It's  not like only "few power users" have server side filtering. Most
business   users   have   it,   especially if they use Exchange. Major
filtering  rules  are  usually set up by server administrator globally
(e.g.  [SPAM] filtering into Spam folder). Also on IMAP users can have
access to other users' mailboxes where mail arrives too.

In  addition,  using  IDLE  command  on  currently selected mailbox is
consisten  behaviour  with  other  email  clients. And there is a good
reason  why,  in  IMAP  phylosophy  INBOX  is just another mailbox, it
really  makes no sense to assume that mail will arrive there. Even the
name for it is configurable and it can be named whatever you want.

With  the rise of Gmail IMAP, most people assume that IMAP
is  just another email protocol. But it is really completely new point
of  view  to  how  email  works.  It  is good of course that Google is
pushing it to mainstream, however I hope that some day it will be much
more than just pop3 on streroids.

-- 
Best regards,
 Vilius


________________________________________________________
 Current beta is 5.0.18.12 | 'Using TBBETA' information:
http://www.silverstones.com/thebat/TBUDLInfo.html

Reply via email to