Hello Stefan,

> Good [morning|afternoon|day|evening|night]  Miguel,

What if it is exactly noon time? ;-)

Thanks for your reply, I appreciate it. See comments below though.

MAU>> I am not familiar with RFCs but common sense (at least my common
MAU>> sense) tells me that the forwarded message should not include an
MAU>> In-Reply-To header. A forward is *not* a reply.
> 
> Well, this is done by intention - in order to make it possible to put
> forwarded in the same thread. This is useful for support desks - you
> see what the message was processed in one way or another...

I do agree with you that putting the forwarded message in the thread
is useful and perhaps even important but, even if the In-Reply-To: was
included intentionally in forwarded messages, I must say that it is
NOT needed at all. Why? Because threading works perfectly just with
the References: header line. Try it if you don't belive me.

I know this because of two reasons:

   - I'm working on a PowePro macro (not tuned yet) to manually thread
   messages (i.e. reply messages coming from Outlook that do not
   include either a In-Reply-To or References header) and the method
   I'm using is to export to *.MSG, adding a References: header line
   and importing. The imported message is properly threaded.

   - I have also just tested this with forwarded messages. Exported to
   *.MSG, deleted the In-Reply-To header and imported. The imported
   copy is also perfectly threaded.

So, my conclusion is that In-Reply-To is not at all needed in
forwarded messages, the References is just enough. And there is no
possible doubt about which message it will thread to, because the
References line in any forwarded message will only include *one*
message ID, the message ID of the original message being forwarded.

And while I talk to you... any plans to include a manual re-threading
option in a near future version of TB? Or should I continue tuning my
PowerPro macro?
   


-- 
Best regards,

Miguel A. Urech (El Escorial - Spain)
Using The Bat! v1.61 on Windows 2000 5.0 Service Pack 3


________________________________________________________
 Current beta is 1.62b17 | "Using TBBETA" information:
http://www.silverstones.com/thebat/TBUDLInfo.html

Reply via email to