Hello Marcus,

Saturday, April 2, 2005, 18:03:29, you wrote:


MO> On Sunday, April 3, 2005, 01:39, hggdh wrote:

MO> Multiple accounts I have used though. What you do when changing
MO> the 'From:' address is just that, changing the 'From:' address.
MO> Changing accounts is made either by right clicking the account
MO> name in the status bar of the editor window, or by selecting
MO> account in Options | Active account.

MO> This is intended behaviour and, according to me, reasonable behaviour as
MO> well. If a change of the 'From:' field would change account as well, I
MO> do not see how I could change the 'From:' address without changing
MO> accounts, something I need to do now and then.

I do not quite agree (and, before we advance, I also have to state
that I do not quite disagree).

My personal view is that an e-mail client should frown on using a
'From:' address that is not configured under a valid account. In other
words, the 'Reply-To' header field has to be a valid reference when
the e-mail leaves the e-mail client.

This, for an e-mail client, would go a long way on having said e-mail
client taken out of some spammer lists.

Which sort of throw us back into the the <off-topic/> issue I raised
in my first e-mail: Comcast should have rejected my reply with a fake
'From:' field -- because this is what is was: a fake email address, as
far as the Comcast environment was concerned.

Please do not get me wrong -- it is still easy for those of us that
play in the Internet standards (IETF, etc) to find out where the
e-mail came from; there is always the legal request to the ISP to
provide this information, as a last resort... and, believe me, if you
show cause, they will. But I still would rather prefer an e-mail
client that enforces such a restriction.



-- 

 ..hggdh..

Using The Bat! v3.0.9.12 Return and  on Windows 2000 5.0 Build  2195
Service Pack 4

Attachment: pgpVDPgu0IjSt.pgp
Description: PGP signature

________________________________________________________
 Current beta is 3.0.9.12 Return | 'Using TBBETA' information:
http://www.silverstones.com/thebat/TBUDLInfo.html
IMPORTANT: To register as a Beta tester, use this link first -
http://www.ritlabs.com/en/partners/testers/

Reply via email to