Hello [EMAIL PROTECTED],

Saturday, May 20, 2006, 7:23:16 AM, you wrote:

M> Hi

M> On Thursday 4 May 2006 at 3:32:04 AM, in
M> <mid:[EMAIL PROTECTED]>, Paul Berger wrote:

>> There was an in-depth discussion here  a few months ago. I don't
>> remember the details, but they supported the -ize ending in nearly all
>> uses.

M> My understanding is that while -ize is standard in the US, in most
M> cases in the UK it is merely an "acceptable" alternative to the
M> usual -ise form. (I repeat my previous comment that to whom it is
M> "acceptable" has never been clear.)

M> I can see an argument for supporting a spelling that is standard
M> one side of the pond and "acceptable" the other side...

>> Harrap's Dictionary of English Usage

M> Never heard of it.

>> Times change.

M> Yes, when I was very young it was trendy and modern to use -ise.
M> -ize was still about but generally going out of fashion.

M> Throughout my school/college career -ize generally cropped up only
M> in old or American texts (except for some reason in the past
M> tense, -ized was much in evidence).

M> A couple of decades later and -ize has gained in popularity once
M> more. I remain convinced this is due to dodgy spell-checkers.  ;-)



I see your point of view. I have no strong feelings either way.


-- 



Paul

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
 Using The Bat! v3.71.03 on Windows XP
5.1 Build 2600 Service Pack 2          

...If people from Poland are called Poles, why aren't people from Holland 
called Holes?


________________________________________________
Current version is 3.80.06 | 'Using TBUDL' information:
http://www.silverstones.com/thebat/TBUDLInfo.html

Reply via email to