hi, > Hi, > > [email protected] (YAMAMOTO Takashi) wrote: >> i have userland implementation of posix shared memory. >> (attached) >> >> rmind proposed a kernel implementation while ago. >> http://mail-index.netbsd.org/tech-kern/2009/07/30/msg005599.html >> (thus cc:) >> >> which way should we go? >> >> IMO userland implementation is better because: >> - simpler >> - smaller >> - a bug would have less impact >> - "locking object in memory" functionality is better to be >> implemented with more generic api like fcntl if necessary > > We should go with the userland implementation. After some though I > basically agree with you that facilities like memory locking can be > implemented with fcntl, mount option tmpfs or whatever. > > However, I would say it would be better to create tmpfs partition > for this. A while ago I came up with practically same code, but > also checking for the fs type: > > http://www.netbsd.org/~rmind/shm.c
i don't think it's a good idea to force fstype. if we want to recommend tmpfs, it's a job for sysinst, not libc. YAMAMOTO Takashi > >> >> YAMAMOTO Takashi > > -- > Mindaugas
