Mumbai : Rudest city on Earth
[complete coverage of the survey,results,counter arguments and comments, take time and read, please do comment on this ]
Mumbai - India's crowded commercial centre Mumbai drives the nation's rapid economic growth but is far too busy to say "thank you," making it the world's rudest city, according to a survey.
Reader's Digest performed a survey recently.
Its about the helping tendency and common courtesy.
Reader's Digest performed a survey recently.
Its about the helping tendency and common courtesy.
They performed three experiments:
"door tests" (would anyone hold one open for them?);
"document drops" (who would help them retrieve a pile of "accidentally" dropped papers?); and
"service tests" (which sales clerks would thank them for a purchase?).
These tests were done undercover, ie, no one knew that they are being tested!
And the results say that Mumbai is the rudest while New York is the most helpful and courteous city.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
The List of cities and their ranking of politeness
| New York | USA | 80% | |||
| Zurich | Switzerland | 77 | |||
| Toronto | Canada | 70 | |||
| Berlin | Germany | 68 | |||
| São Paulo | Brazil | 68 | |||
| Zagreb | Croatia | 68 | |||
| Auckland | New Zealand | 67 | |||
| Warsaw | Poland | 67 | |||
| Mexico City | Mexico | 65 | |||
| Stockholm | Sweden | 63 | |||
| Budapest | Hungary | 60 | |||
| Madrid | Spain | 60 | |||
| Prague | Czech Republic | 60 | |||
| Vienna | Austria | 60 | |||
| Buenos Aires | Argentina | 57 | |||
| Johannesburg | South Africa | 57 | |||
| Lisbon | Portugal | 57 | |||
| London | United Kingdom | 57 | |||
| Paris | France | 57 | |||
| Amsterdam | Netherlands | 52 | |||
| Helsinki | Finland | 48 | |||
| Manila | Philippines | 48 | |||
| Milan | Italy | 47 | |||
| Sydney | Australia | 47 | |||
| Bangkok | Thailand | 45 | |||
| Hong Kong | 45 | ||||
| Ljubljana | Slovenia | 45 | |||
| Jakarta | Indonesia | 43 | |||
| Taipei | Taiwan | 43 | |||
| Moscow | Russia | 42 | |||
| Singapore | 42 | ||||
| Seoul | South Korea | 40 | |||
| Kuala Lumpur | Malaysia | 37 | |||
| Bucharest | Romania | 35 | |||
| Mumbai | India | 32 |
http://india-alive.blogspot.com/2006/06/list-of-cities-and-their-ranking-of.html
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Arguments against the survey
1. On what basis only 35 countries were selected? What were
the criteria chosen in this survey? Why not other countries?
2. Why did Readers Digest research team choose only Mumbai and not any other city in India? Mumbai is known for its commercial characteristics and knowledge hub and in general they are known for their modest behavior. I agree that certain cities in North India may lack some sort of civic sense but not Mumbai at all. I strongly suspect its findings.
3. How did its research team develop the questions which they considered as an indicator of rudeness? Was the questionnaire or criteria developed by experts or social scientists or by using a Delphi technique?
4. Most importantly, I am seriously asking, what was THE RESPONSE BIAS AND NON-RESPONSE BIAS in the survey? To what extent the findings about Mumbai were statistically significant?
5. By simply giving marks, out of 100, they can't draw inferences or conclusions. For this type of survey, the research team should have developed an index.
6. Before drawing inferences, the research team should have considered the cultural dimensions of Asian societies as explained by Professor G. Hofestede. Asian societies are generally more conservative and shy.
They do not mix up easily with strangers. At the same time, they may not say "Thank you" using English language rather may express thanks in their own language. It appears to us that the researchers have biased mind in jumping to conclusions.
7. Even if, I believe that Readers' Diggest survey findings are correct with some margin of error, Mumbaikar rudeness may be 100 times better than the racial discrimination and hatred attitudes shown by people in London, NY, and other major cities in Europe and North America.
8. Mr. Sanjay from Delhi also argues that "possibly Mumbai has ended up bearing the brunt of a faulty methodology, designed by a Western mind for Western cities. This may be the reason why New York has fared so well". This strong possibility may not be ruled out in these survey findings.
Dr. P.L. Joshi, is a Professor, Editor-in-Chief: Int Journal of Acc. Auditing and Peforamnce Evaluation, UK Managing Editor: Afro-Asian Journal of Finance and Accounting. He submitted this article to Asian Tribune.
- Asian Tribune -
2. Why did Readers Digest research team choose only Mumbai and not any other city in India? Mumbai is known for its commercial characteristics and knowledge hub and in general they are known for their modest behavior. I agree that certain cities in North India may lack some sort of civic sense but not Mumbai at all. I strongly suspect its findings.
3. How did its research team develop the questions which they considered as an indicator of rudeness? Was the questionnaire or criteria developed by experts or social scientists or by using a Delphi technique?
4. Most importantly, I am seriously asking, what was THE RESPONSE BIAS AND NON-RESPONSE BIAS in the survey? To what extent the findings about Mumbai were statistically significant?
5. By simply giving marks, out of 100, they can't draw inferences or conclusions. For this type of survey, the research team should have developed an index.
6. Before drawing inferences, the research team should have considered the cultural dimensions of Asian societies as explained by Professor G. Hofestede. Asian societies are generally more conservative and shy.
They do not mix up easily with strangers. At the same time, they may not say "Thank you" using English language rather may express thanks in their own language. It appears to us that the researchers have biased mind in jumping to conclusions.
7. Even if, I believe that Readers' Diggest survey findings are correct with some margin of error, Mumbaikar rudeness may be 100 times better than the racial discrimination and hatred attitudes shown by people in London, NY, and other major cities in Europe and North America.
8. Mr. Sanjay from Delhi also argues that "possibly Mumbai has ended up bearing the brunt of a faulty methodology, designed by a Western mind for Western cities. This may be the reason why New York has fared so well". This strong possibility may not be ruled out in these survey findings.
Dr. P.L. Joshi, is a Professor, Editor-in-Chief: Int Journal of Acc. Auditing and Peforamnce Evaluation, UK Managing Editor: Afro-Asian Journal of Finance and Accounting. He submitted this article to Asian Tribune.
- Asian Tribune -
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
My opinion about the Reader's Digest Survey
Hope you have read about the survey, its results and counter-arguments.
"It really comes down to one word -- respect," says Leonard Berry, director of Texas A&M University's Center for Retailing Studies. "We've collected the most common service complaints, and every one of them is rooted in lack of respect for the customer."
Here are my views on this topic.
Indian shopkeepers have do a long way to go in terms of customer service and customer handling.
Shopkeepers and service providers behave to customers as if the customers are at the mercy of the shopkeepers.
Almost 70% of sellers are like this, and of course there are some good and helpful sellers or merchants.
Indians must improve in the way they handle customers, and sellers must keep in mind that customers provide the money and not the other way around and give due respect to customers.
A small advice to Indians is that, "please be courteous and helpful to customers, whatever maybe your business, this one single attitude will increase your business many-fold".
"It really comes down to one word -- respect," says Leonard Berry, director of Texas A&M University's Center for Retailing Studies. "We've collected the most common service complaints, and every one of them is rooted in lack of respect for the customer."
Here are my views on this topic.
Indian shopkeepers have do a long way to go in terms of customer service and customer handling.
Shopkeepers and service providers behave to customers as if the customers are at the mercy of the shopkeepers.
Almost 70% of sellers are like this, and of course there are some good and helpful sellers or merchants.
Indians must improve in the way they handle customers, and sellers must keep in mind that customers provide the money and not the other way around and give due respect to customers.
A small advice to Indians is that, "please be courteous and helpful to customers, whatever maybe your business, this one single attitude will increase your business many-fold".
posted by bharath
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Blog url : http://india-alive.blogspot.com/
My Blog: Tech blog
Yahoo! India Answers: Share what you know. Learn something new Click here
Catch all the FIFA World Cup 2006 action on Yahoo! India Click here __._,_.___
SPONSORED LINKS
| Technical support | Computer security | Computer technical support |
| Computer training |
YAHOO! GROUPS LINKS
- Visit your group "tech4all" on the web.
- To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to:
[EMAIL PROTECTED]
- Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to the Yahoo! Terms of Service.
