On Thu, Nov 22, 2012 at 11:41 PM, Marc Espie <[email protected]> wrote: > > On Thu, Nov 22, 2012 at 01:27:46PM -0430, Andres Perera wrote: > > why would the runtime be attractive for rop? what configuration vm > > needs syscalls that would be attractive to an attacker that can change > > the address of a jump? does the runtime really need to open sockets, > > or spawn processes? (i'm not even talking about languages) > > [...] > > > i'm completely serious. i can use a js vm and write a trivial systrace > > sandbox like ssh's which only allows read() > > You're only talking about one small aspect of security. Just because your > javascript apps cannot interact with your OS doesn't make them secure.
that's not a specialized condition reserved to js interpreters, and i also don't wish to talk about larger aspects because i'd be entering an area that's dominated by quality of implementation issues that aren't solved by os access control tools > They also have to be reliable, not trample on each other memory, so that > you get predictable behavior and only have to worry about logic errors in > each app. same applies > People are *relying* on javascript to do real work. If you're > depositing documents on servers. If you're using gmail. If you're using > any kind of web app, basically. that's interesting. the subject is about a potential configuration language that is managed by the administrator, such as polkit's and sudo's > > > Every day, people say that high-level languages like java or js are more > secure. They are missing the point. Just because they don't have buffer > overflows doesn't protect them from sloppy developer errors. Just the > opposite, actually: being stupid is no longer a barrier to writing > "production" code, and you end up with idiots writing code, instead of > being stopped right away by C's nastiness. every time i pair malloc() with free(), i don't feel enlightened; i don't feel like wallowing in thoughts of my own self-worth; i don't feel like masturbating intellectually i should know by now, given that i'm 3 months into rewriting infrastrusture/bin/dpb in C
