This is an excellent comparative review. Just one comment with which I disagree 
somewhat.

You said that “Apple and Samsung hate each other”.Not absolutely true. Most,if 
not all, of the new Apple devices use Samsung display modules. So the two 
companies do interact at a lower level, although you’re quite right in saying 
that Apple fiercely guards its App Store, and won’t permit companies like 
Samsung to have their apps sold or distributed there, claiming that Samsun has 
not met the developer specifications which are quite rigorous. Need, Apple is 
currently facing law suits on behalf of a number of companies in the US courts. 
The suits allege that Apple’s anticompetatie practises are in breech of trade 
laws. It will be interesting to see what comes of that, although the US legal 
processes do tend to grind quite slowly. So we may not see any change for quite 
some time to come.

Apple is also facing law suits over the very design of the iPhone XS and XS 
Max. I can’t quite remember who is pursuing Apple on that one, but again, we’ll 
have to see what happens.

There was a law suit outstanding until recently, filed by Intel, again, against 
Apple. This one was over Apple’s decision not to use Intel’s modem chips in the 
new iPhones. I’m not sure what happened here, but I know that it was settled 
out of court.


On 2 Jun 2019, at 07:02, Ted <[email protected]> wrote:


The best truly wireless bluetooth earbuds: Samsung Gear IconX vs Jabra 65T 
(Sorry, Airpods)

 

Ok, so you want earbuds with no cable connecting them.  You want the 
convenience and small form factor, and you also love music.  Which ones do you 
buy?

 

I love earbuds.  In addition to these two sets, I also own the Beats Powerbeats 
3.  Thought it might be useful to do a comparison.

 

Firstly, in terms of pure music quality, truly wireless earbuds can't compete 
with wired ones (this means a cable/wire connecting the two earbuds, not 
referring to a wire connecting to the device you're using such as an iPhone).  
The reason is the form factor size.  The Powerbeats ones are larger because 
they do not go completely into the ear.  The bulk of the electronics sits 
outside the ear, and hooks over via a rubberized hook that goes up and over 
each ear.  They can fit more internal electronics and battery, giving a much 
better music quality and battery life.  My Powerbeats get around 11 hours of 
battery life, with amazing bass and sound quality.

 

However, if you want something even more portable and convenient, easier to put 
in/take out, truly wireless earbuds have come a long way.  The generally two 
best reviewed pairs are the Samsung Gear IconX and the Jabra 65T Elite.  Each 
coming in around $300AU (to be fair, the Jabra were about $269).

 

I bought the Samsung ones first.  They feature a touch interface on each 
earbud, so you do gestures to do things like increase/decrease the volume, 
play/pause, skip forward or back a track, etc.  They also feature internal 
memory of 6GB, allowing you to copy music onto the buds themselves, so you 
don't even have to bring your phone and can still listen to music.

 

Other key features include what is called "pass-through", where you can allow 
ambient noise to enter the earbuds so you can hear the outside environment, 
such as traffic or someone talking to you without having to take the earbuds 
out.

 

What makes the Samsung unique is that normally, one earbud is a "master" and 
another a "slave", meaning you can only use one earbud by itself, not either.  
With the Gear IconX, you can use either earbud on it's own as they each have 
microphones in them.  I primarily use these for work, and use one earbud paired 
to my PC so I can hear Jaws, and use a mobile phone on the other side holding 
the phone to my ear.  I can access my laptop fine and still talk on the phone.

 

The earbuds come with a charging case.  The buds get about 5 hours of battery 
life, and the case holds an additional 10 hours, so you can charge them twice 
fully via the case, which is very sturdy and well made.  It has a small button 
at the back to activate pairing mode, which is tactile and easy to use.  If you 
have a little sight, there are lights on the front of the case indicating green 
lights when the buds are fully charged, or dim red ones if they are not, and a 
light on the back indicating whether the case itself is fully charged.

 

The drawback to the Gear IconX if you're an iPhone user is that Apple and 
Samsung hate each other.  As such, Apple doesn't allow Samsung to make the app 
for you to configure the earbuds.  This is essential as this is how you set the 
equalizer for the buds, and also how you activate the "pass-through" that 
allows you to hear the outside world while using your earbuds.  Note that you 
can use any Android device to do this, so if you have a tablet or Android phone 
handy, you can configure these settings and save them to the buds permanently.  
I do wish they made a gesture to activate/deactivate pass-through, which would 
have been way more handy.

 

I also do not like the touch interface doing swipes and taps on each earbud to 
do functions.  I find them way too sensitive, and easy to make unintentional 
commands.

 

Lastly, in terms of comfort, I found my ears getting sore after 2-3 hours of 
use, so if using these, I recommend buying 3rd party tip replacements.  I chose 
the brand called Compli, which are memory foam tips at a cost of $40AU and 
gives you 6 tips.  Each tip lasts 3-6 months and are way more comfortable.

 

So then I bought the Jabra 65T Elite earbuds.  They also have the pass-through 
features, and can be used equally by iPhone or Android users.  They are a 
little smaller than the Samsung.  They are much more comfortable.  I did not 
need to buy 3rd party tips for them.  Unfortunately they do not work 
independently of each other, so if you want to use only one, it has to be the 
right earbud.  Battery life is great, also at about 5 hours.  Sound quality is 
great on both, but different.  More clear on the Jabra.  A little more 
bass-heavy on the Samsung, but both very good.

 

The form factor could have been better on Jabra in a few ways.  Firstly, the 
case feels cheaper and less durable.  Also, they chose to have a glossy finish, 
which makes the buds feel slippery, and easy to drop when taking out of the 
case.  The Samsung case is much better designed.  However, neither case has 
magnetics in them like the Airpods, which locks them in place.  This is the one 
feature of the Airpods which I find superior to both of these.

 

Jabra's case also features 2X full charges for the earbuds.  Jabra's case uses 
Micro USB, while the Samsung uses USB-C.

 

The Jabra app allows you to configure the earbuds for equalizer, whether the 
'pass-through' feature is enabled by default when you connect them (if you 
choose not to, you can activate it by double-tapping the right earbud).

 

The other feature I like about Jabra is that  all their controls are physical, 
and thus a bit more reliable than Samsung's touch interface.

 

All in all, I rate both of these earbud sets highly, and I definitely use them 
both every day, but for different things.  If I had to choose one and could not 
keep them both, I'd have to go the Jabra due to being an iPhone user, but if 
you use Android, Gear IconX would be an equally good choice and comes down to 
personal preference.

 

By the way, why did I say "sorry Airpods"?  I actually bought them before I 
bought both of these alternatives, and returned them after a week.  I found the 
sound quality sub-par, and also always felt like they were going to fall out of 
my ears.  Both of these sets 'lock' into your ears almost like screwing a screw 
and fit snugly.  I go to gym, and never feel like I'm going to lose either of 
these.  Airpods always felt the opposite.  They're also ugly hanging down out 
of each ear.  The best feature of Airpods is that, like Samsung, can be used 
each one on its own if you prefer, and also the 'find my Airpods' feature where 
you can make the earbuds emit a sound if you've dropped one.  Airpods also have 
a magnetic case, giving you confidence that they are locked in place and 
charging when you put them in the case.  But in terms of sound quality and 
sound isolation, they aren't in the same league as either of these.

 

Hope this has been useful.  Happy shopping.

 

Ted

 
 
Best Regards,
Ted
[email protected] <mailto:[email protected]>
____________________________

Attachment: smime.p7s
Description: S/MIME cryptographic signature

Reply via email to