Dear list and conference members,
I hope that my earlier message helped clarified some of the points raised regarding the Messaging Design Pattern (Concrete examples, MDP application in distributed Models/systems, code/implementation examples, etc). I'm glad that the main aspects of the MDP/messaging concept were conveyed. There are several points where we are in complete agreement: a) MDP improves decoupling, flexibility and encapsulation b) Messaging is not encapsulation. They are different ideas. MDP only claims that messaging improve encapsulation: "The messaging design pattern allows the interchange of information (i.e. messages) between components and applications. It improves decoupling, encapsulation and reusability by separating component communication from component functionality." c) MDP works well for larger components. I also can provide examples that show that MDP can be used for components of all sizes. For instance ALL the components of the Jt design pattern framework use MDP. It is not difficult at all. It presents all the advantages discussed in both papers. However it requires a shift in terms of thinking (geared towards independent components communicating via messaging). d) The name messaging is often confused with other concepts and technologies (JMS, etc). Some people like the name. They have posted their comments to the mailing list. We thought about finding a better name. On the other hand, MDP is about messaging and transference/interchange of information. e) I like the comment related to the application of MDP to update components in 24/7 systems. We didn't think of it. If possible, I plan to include it in future revisions of the pattern. f) The paper doesn't contain a lot of implementation details. It is not the main focus of the paper. Some references are provided:The Jt design Pattern framework should cover many of the implementation related questions. It is a complete implementation of MDP. The second paper (Messaging Design Pattern and a distributed Component/Service Model) includes some implementation related aspects: https://jt.dev.java.net/files/documents/5553/149793/MDPdistributedModel.pdf I plan to provide answers to the other points/comments that have being raised. Regards,
_______________________________________________ telecom-patterns mailing list [email protected] http://lists.cs.uiuc.edu/mailman/listinfo/telecom-patterns
