Mark, It is a controversial issue but some recent data, including the direct measurements of recharge before and after cedar removal above monitored caves in the San Antonio area, indicates that cutting cedar my not provide the benefit that many folks have thought in regards to recharging water. It will certainly improve pasture lands.
There is a lot of antidotal information from ranchers that indicate they've had springs return after clearing cedar. However, this is difficult to evaluate because of the lack of controlled studies. For example, if you cut cedar off your property between September 2007 and September 2009, what you would find is that you cut the cedar during the driest two year period on record (in the San Antonio area) and also one of the hottest two years on record. What you might find is that in January 2010, your spring started flowing again. Is this because you cut the cedar or is it because we are in the wettest 6 month period on record (October 2009 to March 2010) or both. I'm not sure that folks realize how land degradation from overgrazing has certainly been an issue in central Texas since Europeans have moved onto the landscape. This is a result of overgrazing and suppression of fire as well as other factors. The landscape seems to be relatively resilient. For example, photos taken of the Punkin Cave entrance in the 1960's show a limestone pavement with virtually no vegetation. Most of the limestone pavement on the surface at the Deep and Punkin Nature Preserve shows pitting (cockpit karren) which is generally formed beneath soils (which aren't there now). The area is now covered with dense cedar and lots of exposed bedrock. Currently, there are insufficient soils to support an extensive grassland at this time but over time, may be restored. Geary From: [email protected] [mailto:[email protected]] Sent: Thursday, March 11, 2010 10:49 AM To: Geary Schindel; [email protected] Subject: RE: [Texascavers] FW: Groundwater Recharge and Vegetative Cover study by TA&M Interesting article, Geary. I was struck by the paragraph below: "This area was basically converted from grassland to shrubland after many years of heavy livestock grazing. What people have forgotten is that in the time period between healthy grasslands and the current shrublands, there was an extended period when the land was quite degraded. Subsequent to 1960, livestock numbers have declined and the landscape has recovered although there are now more cedar than in the past," Wilcox explains. Is this article suggesting that we quit cutting down cedar, as I have seen (and done) on many cave projects and ranches? Curious, Mark ________________________________ From: Geary Schindel [mailto:[email protected]] Sent: Thu 3/11/2010 10:43 AM To: [email protected] Subject: [Texascavers] FW: Groundwater Recharge and Vegetative Cover study by TA&M Here is a release of a recent study completed by Brad Wilcox with Texas A&M regarding groundwater recharge and vegetative cover. Geary http://www.agu.org/news/press/pr_archives/2010/2010-06.shtml#content Texas surprise: When trees, shrubs replace grasses, water flows can increase AGU Release No. 10-06 4 March 2010 For Immediate Release
